Maternity care providers’ perceptions of women’s autonomy and the law

Abstract

BackgroundLike all health care consumers, pregnant women have the right to make autonomous decisions about their medical care. However, this right has created confusion for a number of maternity care stakeholders, particularly in situations when a woman’s decision may lead to increased risk of harm to the fetus. Little is known about care providers’ perceptions of this situation, or of their legal accountability for outcomes experienced in pregnancy and birth. This paper examined maternity care providers’ attitudes and beliefs towards women’s right to make autonomous decisions during pregnancy and birth, and the legal responsibility of professionals for maternal and fetal outcomes.MethodsAttitudes and beliefs around women’s autonomy and health professionals’ legal accountability were measured in a sample of 336 midwives and doctors from both public and private health sectors in Queensland, Australia, using a questionnaire available online and in paper format. Student’s t-test was used to compare midwives’ and doctors’ responses.ResultsBoth maternity care professionals demonstrated a poor understanding of their own legal accountability, and the rights of the woman and her fetus. Midwives and doctors believed the final decision should rest with the woman; however, each also believed that the needs of the woman may be overridden for the safety of the fetus. Doctors believed themselves to be ultimately legally accountable for outcomes experienced in pregnancy and birth, despite the legal position that all health care professionals are responsible only for adverse outcomes caused by their own negligent actions. Interprofessional differences were evident, with midwives and doctors significantly differing in their responses on five of the six items.ConclusionsMaternity care professionals inconsistently supported women’s right to autonomous decision making during pregnancy and birth. This finding is further complicated by care providers’ poor understanding of legal accountability for outcomes experienced in pregnancy and birth. The findings of this study support the need for guidelines on decision making in pregnancy and birth for maternity care professionals, and for recognition of interprofessional differences in beliefs around the rights of the woman, her fetus and health professionals in order to facilitate collaborative practice.

Measuring labor and delivery unit culture and clinicians’ attitudes toward birth: Revision and validation of the Labor Culture Survey

“…[29][30][31] This theme did not emerge either in our search of published survey items, the preliminary work done by CMQCC, or in our qualitative focus groups; however, it certainly is important work for the future as the survey is used in states other than California and among a more diverse range of hospitals with and without religious affiliations. The electronic format of the survey may have biased our sample toward those more familiar with email and regularly using technology.…”

A postgraduate Optimum Birth module to increase midwives’ readiness to work in midwifery‐led settings: A mixed‐methods evaluation

“…1,9,12 Confidence improved after the module as all except one participant reported good or excellent self-confidence. 20 Qualitative comments alluded to increased self-confidence in challenging staff that were not perceived as working in an evidence-based manner. 19 Midwives' ability to talk to women and facilitate women's choices also improved after the training.…”

Is the narrow concept of individual autonomy compatible with or in conflict with Evidence-based Medicine in obstetric practice?

“…The driving and legally relevant factor in decision-making is the women's so-called autonomy. But it is largely unclear what obstetricians and/or lawyers mean when they talk about autonomy (Kruske et al 2013).…”