Materiality Assessment of Natural Capital Risks in Australian Forestry

Abstract

Purpose of Review Natural capital is a term for the stocks of natural assets (e.g. natural resources and ecosystems) that yield flows of ecosystem services that benefit the economy and human well-being. Forestry is one of the industries with the greatest dependencies on natural capital, as well as having the potential for substantial positive or negative impacts on natural capital. These dependencies and impacts create direct risks to a forestry enterprise’s ongoing financial viability, which translate into indirect risks for investors and society. There are growing demands from a variety of stakeholders for more reliable information to assess such risks, but at present, these risks are not always well understood, assessed or communicated in a consistent and comparable way. This paper addresses this problem by applying a standardized methodology to develop the first systematic, evidence-based review and financial materiality assessment of natural capital risks for the Australian forestry sector. Recent Findings The vast potential scope of forestry impacts and dependencies on natural capital can be reduced to twenty key areas of relevance to Australian forestry, of which only seven to nine have been assessed as highly financially material for each of the sub-sectors of softwood plantations, hardwood plantations and native forestry. The majority of risks assessed as highly financially material are related to dependencies on natural capital. This is in part due to the fact that current regulations and certification schemes focus on managing impacts, but tend to overlook dependencies. Nearly all of the natural capital risks rated as highly material are likely to be exacerbated by climate change. Summary An improved understanding of natural capital risks is an important input to better decision-making by forestry enterprises, as well as their lenders and investors, forestry regulators and other relevant stakeholders. This paper contributes to the preparedness of the forestry industry and its stakeholders to address questions about vulnerability to future changes and declining trends in natural capital.

An introduction to financial opportunities, ecological concepts, and risks underpinning aspirations for a nature-positive economy

“…It is now recognised that human well-being and resilience and stability of Earth systems are inseparably linked, and that systemic action is needed to safeguard the planet for current and future generations (Brondizio et al 2019, Rockström et al 2023. In turn, the global business community is realising the critical importance of nature to the economy, as that their supply chains, operations, and business values are increasingly affected by the consequences of depleted and degraded nature (Smith et al 2021).…”

“…Nature will benefit by being more explicitly accounted for in business (zu Ermgassen et al 2022), while corporations can mitigate nature-related risks (e.g. Smith et al 2021) and create market opportunities through a range of new mechanisms (TNFD 2022a). The challenge is significant.…”

“…The typology builds on the work of Pirard (2012), who created a lexicon for market-based instruments (regulations that encourage behaviour through market signals rather than through explicit directives) building on (Stavins 2003). In expanding on Pirard (2012) we consider not only market-based instruments, but also a broader set of financial instruments including equity and debt-based instruments which may be an important part of future business operating models in the nature-positive economy (Table 1)this builds on Smith et al (2020) who defined financial instruments in the context of sustainable forestry in Australia.…”

Study on the impact of green finance on green total factor productivity in forestry—evidence from China

“…Forestry is mainly a labor-intensive industry relying on natural capital (Smith et al, 2021), with a single industrial structure limited by geographic and biological factors, a cyclical growth pattern, and a significant reliance on artificial seeding, pest control, and irrigation. Human capital plays an irreplaceable and vital role in forestry production.…”