Martial arts participation and externalizing behavior in juveniles: A meta-analytic review

Abstract

Martial arts are very popular among juveniles all over the world, but the relation between martial arts and externalizing behavior in juveniles remains unclear. The current multilevel meta-analysis of 12 studies, including 94 effect sizes and N = 5949 juveniles, was conducted to examine the relation between martial arts participation and externalizing behavior in juveniles, and to examine factors with a possible moderating effect. Results showed that there was no overall relation between martial arts participation and externalizing behavior in juveniles. However, a trim-and-fill procedure implicated publication bias of studies reporting that juvenile martial artist showed more externalizing behavior than non-martial artists, suggesting that the current overall outcomes might underestimate externalizing behavior in martial artists. Moderator analyses showed that studies published in higher impact factor journals, and studies with a higher training intensity in martial arts found more externalizing behavior in martial artists. Furthermore, karate was found to be less related to externalizing behavior than judo. Finally, in comparison with non-athletes and team sport athletes, martial artists showed similar levels of externalizing behavior, but they showed more externalizing behavior when compared to individual sport athletes. Implications for future policy and research are discussed.

Does Pre-Competitive Anxiety Interfere in the Performance of Boxing Athletes in Brazil? A Pilot Study

“…These anxiogenic levels may vary depending on the situation. 20 Therefore, it has been demonstrated that there should be an ideal level of anxiety for each athlete, considering that the state of intensity should be compatible with the nature of the activity, so that favorable results can be obtained. 17 In this sense, high-performance boxing athletes in Brazil should not only enjoy physical, technical, tactical, nutritional, and medical preparation, but also psychological 16 preparation.…”

Fighting Gender Stereotypes: Women’s Participation in the Martial Arts, Physical Feminism and Social Change

“…Specifically, because martial art training is one of the most popular sports activities among adolescents in the West [Gubbels et al 2016], learning how to teach and guide, through one's body, developing an ethics of care (in which helping others develop skills is a central goal) can significantly and positively calibrate masculinity. Martial arts can serve as an arena in which certain forms of touch can be interpreted as reassuring, or part of a learning experience, etc., rather than as sexual, or arousing, or homophobic, etc.…”

COREMatters: A Bullying Intervention Pilot Study

“…Although evidence on the benefits of martial arts study is ample in the literature, research examining martial arts as interventions for violence, aggression, and bullying is sparse and inconsistent. Some evidence suggests no significant association between martial arts participation and juvenile anger and aggression (Gubbels, van der Stouwe, Spruit, & Stams, 2016), while other research indicates that martial arts are associated with higher levels of anger and violence (Lotfian, Ziaee, Amini, & Mansournia, 2011;Mutz, 2012;Ziaee, Lotfian, Amini, Mansournia, & Memari, 2012). Still other research asserts that martial arts are associated with decreased externalizing behaviors (Harwood, Lavidor, & Rassovsky, 2017;Twemlow et al, 2008;Vertonghen & Theeboom, 2010).…”

“…Type of martial arts studied may be another moderating factor in the association with aggression and violence. Classical martial arts styles such as karate have traditionally been associated with less aggression than boxing or judo (Gubbels et al, 2016), Further, Milligan et al (2017 found that when integrated with mindfulness approaches, such as increased acceptance of the present moment as well as awareness of thoughts and bodily sensations, even mixed martial arts (MMA)traditionally viewed as an aggressive style of martial arts-was associated with social and emotional benefits (Milligan et al, 2017).…”