Marginalized engineering students' narrative construction through photo elicitation

Abstract

PurposeThe goal of this study is to explore an immediate step in understanding the lived experiences of under-represented students through metaphor construction and possibly collect more in-depth data through photograph-based interviews.Design/Methodology/ApproachThis article introduced photo-elicitation based narrative interviews as a qualitative methodology while interviewing fourteen undergraduate community college students mostly from underrepresented groups (URGs). At the beginning of each interview, the authors probed the participants with 8 photographs chosen by the research team to represent a diverse set of experiences in engineering. The authors conducted a thematic analysis of the interview data.FindingsThe findings suggested that the inclusion of photo-elicitation often catalyzed consumption of representations, images, metaphors, and voice to stories passed unnoticed; and finally produces more detailed descriptions and complements semi-structured narrative interviews.Research Limitations/ImplicationsThis study advances the scholarship that extends photograph driven interviews/photo elicitation methodology while interviewing marginalized population and offers a roadmap for what a multi-modal, arts-based analysis process might look like for in-depth interviews.Practical ImplicationsThe use of photo-elicitation in our research enabled a deeper, more poignant exploration of the URG students' experience of navigating engineering. The participants were able to relate to the photographs and shared their life narratives through them; hence, use of photographs can be adapted in future research.Social ImplicationsOur research revealed that PEI has excellent potential to capture marginalized narratives of URGs, which is not well explored in educational research, specially, in higher education. In our research, PEI promoted more culturally inclusive approaches positioning the participants as experts of their own narratives.Originality/ValueThe study presented in this paper serves as an example of qualitative research that expands methodological boundaries and centers the role of power, marginalization, and creativity in research. This work serves as a unique and important contribution to the photo-elicitation literature, offering a critical roadmap for researchers who are drawn to photo elicitation/photograph driven interviews as a method to explore their inquiry.

What comes to count as sustainable in Rosendal? : a study of how sustainability is being reproduced in an urban sociomaterial assemblage

“…Further, the method is seen to decrease power imbalances between the researcher and the researched due to the research participants' active role in generating data (Bates et al 2017;Rumpf 2017). Participants are often referred to as experts (Rose 2016: 316;Pyyry et al 2021;Maitra & Coley 2022) and seen as collaborators in knowledge production (Auken et al 2010;Rumpf 2017;Lewis Ellison & Enriquez 2021). These perspectives echo those of PAR discussed earlier in the chapter.…”

Photovoice: Visualizing the engineering identity experiences of sophomore students

“…Scholars have recently embraced visual representations to understand better college student experiences (Kelly & Kortegast, 2018;Kortegast et al, 2019;McGowan, 2017;Metcalfe, 2012). Within the context of college students majoring in engineering, newer studies have primarily used photo-elicitation (Berdanier et al, 2018;Herrera et al, 2023;Maitra & Coley, 2022) to illuminate their trajectories. Photo-elicitation is "a qualitative interview technique where participants are asked to take photographs relating to the concept under study, which are then used as triggers for underlying memories and feelings during a subsequent interview" (Tonge et al, 2013, p. 41).…”