Managing Uncertainty During the Communication of Diagnostic Test Information Between Patients and Clinicians in Australian Emergency Care

Abstract

We sought (a) an inductive understanding of patient and clinician perspectives and experiences of the communication of diagnostic test information and (b) a normative understanding of the management of uncertainty that occurs during the clinical encounter in emergency care. Between 2016 and 2018, 58 interviews were conducted with patients and nursing, medical, and managerial staff. Interview data were sequentially analyzed through an inductive thematic analysis, then a normative theory of uncertainty management. Themes of “Ideals,” “Service Efficiency,” and “Managing Uncertainty” were inductively identified as influencing the communication of diagnostic test information. A normative theory of uncertainty management highlighted (a) how these themes reflected the interaction’s sociocultural context, encapsulated various criteria by which clinicians and patients evaluated the appropriateness and effectiveness of their communication, and represented competing goals during the clinical encounter, and (b) how systemic tensions between themes accounted for when diagnostic test information communication occurred, was deferred or avoided.

Modes of Interaction in Naturally Occurring Medical Encounters With General Practitioners: The “One in a Million” Study

“…Doctors and patients have to navigate possibilities, and if doctors assert certainty, they expose themselves to the possibility of being wrong. Conceptualization of uncertainty is "a potential safeguard against diagnostic error" ( Miao et al, 2020Miao et al, , p. 1295. That patients embrace this way of talking is less expected; it might be that they somehow align to the ways in which GPs talk.…”

From Danger to Uncertainty: Changing Health Care Practices, Everyday Experiences, and Temporalities in Dealing With COVID-19 Policies in the Netherlands

“…Following the study of Cohen (1995) on the way parents deal with the uncertainties in treatments of their sick children, Parry (2003) argues that uncertainties too narrowly have been approached as a threat triggering coping. Her research among former cancer patients suggests that uncertainties can be an opportunity for “growth” (see also Miao et al, 2020 ).…”

Power Sharing in Medical Consultations

“…The doctor strives to understand the patient's personality to provide a full understanding of his illness 18 . This relation is entirely different from the role of doctor being paternalistic, and can be compared to an adultto-adult relationship 19 . There is a shift from the paternalistic attitude to mutual participation, giving each party an equal power relation 20 .…”