Managing Soil Organic Carbon: A Farm Perspective

Abstract

SummaryFarming practices that lead to declining returns and inputs of carbon to soils pose a threat to key soil functions. The EU FP7 interdisciplinary project SmartSOIL is using scientific testing and modeling to identify management practices that can optimise soil carbon storage and crop productivity. A consultation with advisors and policymakers in six European case study regions seeks to identify barriers to, and incentives for, uptake of such practices. Results from preliminary interviews are reported. Overall advisor and farmer awareness of management practices specifically directed towards soil carbon is low. Most production‐related decisions are taken in the short term, but managing soil carbon needs a long‐term approach. Key barriers to uptake of practices include: perceived scientific uncertainty about the efficacy of practices; lack of real life ‘best practice’ examples to show farmers; difficulty in demonstrating the positive effects of soil carbon management practices and economic benefits over a long time scale; and advisors being unable to provide suitable advice due to inadequate information or training. Most farmers are unconvinced of the economic benefits of practices for managing soil carbon. Incentives are therefore needed, either as subsidies or as evidence of the cost effectiveness of practices. All new measures and advice should be integrated into existing programmes to avoid a fragmented policy approach.

Strategies for greenhouse gas emissions mitigation in Mediterranean agriculture: A review

“…In forage cropping systems, leguminous species can improve the forage quality and therefore the economic profit (Rochon et al, 2004;Kalac, 2011). Crop rotations (particularly those which involve legumes) are included in the greening requirements of the European Union Common Agricultural Policy (EU CAP) incentives (crop diversification), thus encouraging implementation among farmers (Ingram et al, 2014).…”

Management of agricultural soils for greenhouse gas mitigation: Learning from a case study in NE Spain

“…The results illustrate the large potential to mitigate GHG emissions that the EU-27 regions have by increasing the adoption of SOC management practices. However, the farmer's awareness of and attitudes toward practices that contribute towards improved soil carbon (Cook and Ma 2014), the farming systems and the agronomic and climate conditions vary considerably across the European regions (Ingram et al 2014).…”

“…However, it is clear that smart soil management leads to improved soil health, reduced soil degradation and increased soil carbon, and reduced emissions (Lal 2013). Therefore soil management changes will benefit soil carbon stocks and, in turn, optimise crop productivity (Ingram et al 2014;Lal 2004, Freibahuer 2004Smith 2012).…”

What drives farmers to increase soil organic matter? Insights from the Netherlands

“…Farmers need to balance these objectives, which can prevent implementation of practices to increase SOM content of their topsoil. This can become especially challenging when short‐term profits outweigh long‐term objectives (Ingram et al ., ; Mandryk, ).…”