Managerial Leadership Style and Employee Commitment: Evidence from the Financial Sector

Abstract

Employees’ poor performance within the banking sector has become evident in recent times, and studies on how leadership styles affect employee commitment in the Ghanaian banking sector is scanty. The purpose of this article is to examine the effect of leadership styles on employee commitment after controlling for demographic and institutional factors. The study also examines whether there is a difference in the leadership style due to the gender of leaders and determines the dominant leadership style among bank managers. A sample of 160 leaders and subordinates were selected from 10 commercial banks. The study employed hierarchical regression as well as independent sample t-test techniques. Financial organizations were chosen because much of the existing studies on leadership styles have focussed on non-financial sectors. The findings of the study indicate that transactional leadership is the most dominant leadership style practised within the banking sector. After controlling for demographic and institutional variables, laissez-faire and transformational leadership behaviours have significant positive effects on employee commitment. Although transactional leadership style is dominant, it contributes only 4.8 per cent to employee commitment as compared to 51 per cent by transformational leadership style in eliciting employee commitment. There is an evidence that, married employees are more likely to be committed employees than the unmarried, but as the employee’s number of children increases, commitment level falls. Although all the three leadership styles have positive effects on employee commitment, transactional and laissez-faire leadership styles are most significant. This is the first study in Ghana to show that there is no significant difference between the sexes when it comes to exhibiting leadership styles in the banking sector. The findings of this study provide useful information for policy-makers to improve employees’ commitment levels and their performance by means of stimulating the right leadership styles in the managers.

Influence of Leadership Style, Work Culture and Work Satisfaction on Employee Engagement in The Ministry of Defense of The Republic of Indonesia

“…The results of this study are in line with Weinberger's leadership (2009), which is stated the interaction, relationships, and influence between leaders and those they lead. Leadership can also function based on the leader's power to invite, influence, and move people to do something, for the achievement of certain goals (Tuffour, Gali, & Tuffour, 2019). According to Walter Nordi (Vermeeren, Kuipers, & Steijn, 2014), leadership is an ability to influence the flow of energy and funds available to achieve a goal that is different from other goals.…”

Assessing the Effect of Financial Literacy Among Managers on the Performance of Small-Scale Enterprises

“…Various studies have been conducted on aspects of small enterprises to the exclusion of financial literacy, including challenges, which are experienced across the entire value chain of the operational areas (Appiah et al, 2018; Ayyagari et al, 2007; Quartey et al, 2017); competition (Appiah et al, 2018; Bouazza, Ardjouman, & Abada, 2015); entrepreneurial capabilities (Bouazza et al, 2015; Kazimoto, 2014); innovation (Tuffour, Agbaam, Edzeame, Aye-Darko, & Darko, 2018), managerial leadership (Tuffour, Abubakari, & Tuffour, 2019; Tuffour, Banor, & Akuffo, 2015), human resource capabilities (Adomako, Danso, & Damoah, 2016; Pant, Lapres, Olafsen, Ronchi, & Cook, 2018); technological capabilities (Anderson, 2017; Cirera & Maloney, 2017), business success of micro-entrepreneurs (Chatterjee & Das, 2016), technical efficiency (Charoenrat & Harvie, 2017), dimensions of human capital in SMEs (education, knowledge, experience and skills) (Dar & Mishra, 2019) and managerial capabilities (Quartey et al, 2017). This gap in the literature on Ghana needs to be filled, and the present study addresses the problem.…”

Transformational leadership: an antecedent for organizational effectiveness in Indian banks

“…Indeed it can be inferred from the nature of tasks and required outcomes that leadership style of the leaders who are responsible for creating and delivering service is an important determinant for fulfilling strategic demands and challenges in the banking sector (Berber et al , 2019). Though the significance of leadership on OE, particularly in the Indian banking sector, has already been investigated in several studies (Tuffour et al , 2019; Mitra, 2020), the influence of “transformational leadership” (TL) style has not yet been examined in this area. TL works to improve efficiency and effectiveness in the organization i.e.…”