Male Scientists’ Competing Devotions to Work and Family: Changing Norms in a Male-Dominated Profession

Abstract

Using in-depth interviews with 74 men across different ranks in biology and physics at prestigious US universities, we ask to what extent changing norms of fatherhood and a flexible workplace affect men working in a highly male-dominated profession and what variation exists in family forms. We conceptualize four typologies of men: those forgoing children, egalitarian partners, neo-traditional dual-earners, and traditional breadwinners. Findings suggest male scientists hold strong work devotions yet a growing number seek egalitarian relationships, which they frame as reducing their devotion to work. The majority of men find the all-consuming nature of academic science conflicts with changing fatherhood norms.

The New STEM Faculty Profile: Balancing Family and Dual Careers

“…This system reflects a culture that assumed that a faculty member could focus entirely on getting a tenure, either by being single or by having a stay-at-home partner (usually a wife) who provided all of the childcare and homecare for the family. In addition, the partner often did typing and other unpaid labor to support the husband's academic career (Damaske, Ecklund, Lincoln, & White, 2014)). The tenure system thus assumed a supported male as the "ideal worker" and his behavior the "ideal worker norm" (Drago et al, 2006;Williams, 2001).…”

The Pressure-Status Nexus and Blurred Work–Family Boundaries

“…The theoretical basis for anticipating gender differences in our focal hypotheses revolves around the long-standing articulation of the gendered nature of work and the work-family border (Damaske, Ecklund, Lincoln, & White, 2014;Yaish & Stier, 2009). In particular, this provides a gendered view of border theory and its description of permeability in ways that help elaborate on the hypotheses described earlier.…”

Two steps forward, one step back? Strengthening the foundations of women’s leadership in higher education

“…As Williams (2003Williams ( , 2005 observes, the "ideal worker" is someone whose commitment to work (time) is unlimited, who can move at will (or seek outside offers for salary reasons), and needs no time off for childbearing, child-rearing, or elder care. Since academics average longer hours than most professionals, they may be especially susceptible to this demand for devotion to work (Damaske et al 2014). When academic work is governed by these gendered institutional norms and practices, women are at a distinct disadvantage.…”