The time course of intramolecular isotope distribution in phosphoglyceric acid and serine was determined after exposure of grape leaf discs (Vitis vinifera L.) to (8,19,23,24,28), whereas the respective position of this ubiquitous dicarboxylic acid in photosynthetic C3 metabolism remains to be clarified. Based on the observation that isotope distribution in citric acid after assimilation of 14C02 reflected little recycling of oxaloacetate through tricarboxylic acid cycle reactions, a dual anaplerotic function of malic acid by providing both, the C2 and C4 fragments for citrate synthesis, was suggested (16). Apart from this uncertainty concerning the mechanism of malate remetabolization in plants fixing CO2 directly via Calvin cycle reactions, the effective metabolic precursor of malate in the C3 system is controversial also. While pulse-chase experiments with spinach leaf slices gave evidence for a considerable carbon flow from photosynthetic C3 products to malate (3, 4), incongruent labeling patterns of alanine-as a representative of the C3 pathway-and citrate after fixation of 14C02 by Viciafaba were taken as indicative for a 'non-Calvin cycle origin' of the tricarboxylic acid cycle intermediates, including malic acid (13)(14)(15).The present paper reexamines the existence and functioning of a proposed precursor-product relationship between seine and malate in C3 plants (17) by comparative analysis of the labeling patterns of PGA, seine, and malic acid from grape leaf discs after exposure to 14C02 for variable metabolic periods.