“…Other statements (e.g., “programs with higher time commitments in outpatient hospital settings, in adult day care, in group homes, and in chronic care hospitals attracted fewer applicants than their counterparts”) are not presented in sufficient detail to judge whether the authors' conclusions are correct. The authors also claim that geriatrics fails to demonstrate a defined knowledge base either in its teaching or its research; this claim is contradicted by a burgeoning literature 8–10 …”