‘Mail-order brides’ in popular culture: Colonialist representations and absent discourse

Abstract

Over the past decade clever marketing and wider access to the internet has led to the exponential growth of ‘mail-order’ marriage industries, vastly increasing the number of women who migrate for marriage using these commercial services. Taken within the context of global predatory capitalism, such phenomenon is of interest in that it appears to convene in its dynamics the intersecting operation of gender and class inequality, sexism, racism, and colonialism that, far from diminishing, seems only to further intensify with the increase in transnational cross-border traffic between populations. In this study, we investigate the complicity of knowledge-production practices within popular culture in the perpetuation of such dynamics within the ‘mail-order’ marriage industry. In particular, we focus on the politics of representation around the figure of the so-called ‘mail-order bride’ as produced in various genres and sites in North America over the past 15 years. Our study revealed, as expected, an intensely narrow and colonialist discourse constituting the women involved in such commercial transactions as commodity objects, victims, or victimizers. But, as well, we found five potentially counter-hegemonic works that serve to represent an alternative discourse that at least gestures toward a more diverse and complex representation of these women and of married life, employing devices such as irony, parody, spoofing, and other tongue-in-cheek references. However, as our conclusion demonstrates, despite such admirable interventions, some aspects of agency-arranged marriages remain utterly absent in North American popular culture, thereby perpetuating and ultimately failing to displace the dominant discourse on this population of women.

Crossing Social Boundaries in an Immigration Context: Exogamy and Gendered Employment Patterns in Unions in Germany

“…A recent study on non-migrants in several European countries explored individual attitudes of non-migrants in exogamous and endogamous unions toward gender equality [ 10 ], and found that non-migrants in mixed unions were more supportive of gender equality than their counterparts in endogamous unions. This finding contradicts the stereotyping that often occurs in the media [ 108 ] or in research on mixed marriages, such as studies on German men who are married to women from Asia [ 66 ] or on German women who are in romantic relationships with men from Sub-Saharan Africa [ 11 ].…”

Orientalist Representations in Reality TV: A Critical Discourse Analysis

“…A very common trope in the show is the question of whether to work out, then the newcomer must go back to their home country. This corresponds to the stereotype that women from non-Western countries are victims that need saving to get out of their home country (Zare and Mendoza, 2012). This, then, positions the American as the saviour.…”

The Russian Cyber‐Bride as Geopolitical Fantasy

“…They emerged again after the Vietnam War and the closure of US military bases in the Philippines during the 1990s as well as in post‐Cold War Europe (Enloe ). Both the more traditional ‘mail‐order brides’ and the more recent ‘cyber‐brides’ seem to appear where patriarchy and capitalism meet the dynamics of colonisation and post‐colonisation (Zare & Mendoza ).…”