“…For Na þ and K þ , the difference in ion-ligand interaction energy, hU il Na i ðNaÞ − hU il K i ðKÞ , is always a large negative number (favorable), whereas the corresponding difference in ligandligand interaction, hU ll i ðNaÞ − hU ll i ðKÞ , is more typically a positive number (unfavorable) (32). Thermodynamically, the mean ionligand interaction does not give rise to selectivity in the confined microdroplet limit, in contrast with the host-guest mechanism with fixed cavity radius as described by [13]. The lack of selectivity from the mean ion-ligand interaction has been documented very clearly by Asthagiri et al (24).…”