Colloidal clusters and gels are ubiquitous in science
and technology.
Particle softness has a strong effect on interparticle interactions;
however, our understanding of the role of this factor in the formation
of colloidal clusters and gels is only beginning to evolve. Here,
we report the results of experimental and simulation studies of the
impact of particle softness on the assembly of clusters and networks
from mixtures of oppositely charged polymer nanoparticles (NPs).
Experiments were performed below or above the polymer glass transition
temperature, at which the interaction potential and adhesive forces
between the NPs were significantly varied. Hard NPs assembled in fractal
clusters that subsequently organized in a kinetically arrested colloidal
gel, while soft NPs formed dense precipitating aggregates, due to
the NP deformation and the decreased interparticle distance. Importantly,
interactions of hard and soft NPs led to the formation of discrete
precipitating NP aggregates at a relatively low volume fraction of
soft NPs. A phenomenological model was developed for interactions
of oppositely charged NPs with varying softnesses. The experimental
results were in agreement with molecular dynamics simulations based
on the model. This work provides insight on interparticle interactions
before, during, and after the formation of hard–hard, hard–soft,
and soft–soft contacts and has impact for numerous applications
of reversible colloidal gels, including their use as inks for additive
manufacturing.