Lunch is ready& but not healthy: An analysis of lunches served in childcare centres in two Canadian provinces

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Childcare centres (CCs) typically offer one meal and snacks daily. This study compared what is served in CCs with what the nutritional recommendations are; described and compared the nutritional composition of lunches served in CCs in New Brunswick and Saskatchewan; and examined differences between French and English, and urban and rural centres. METHODS:The study involved 61 randomly selected CCs in New Brunswick and Saskatchewan, Canada. Lunch content was measured on two consecutive days by weighing each food item served to children and by visually documenting the food items using digital photography. Food items were categorized into food groups according to Health Canada's Eating Well with Canada's Food Guide, and nutrients were analyzed using a nutritional analysis software. Onesample t tests compared lunch content with nutritional recommendations. Independent t tests compared the nutrient and food group content of lunches in New Brunswick and Saskatchewan, French and English, and urban and rural CCs. RESULTS:On average, CCs did not meet provincial recommendations. Lunches in both provinces were low in calories (<517 kcal) and fibre (<7 g). Overall, Saskatchewan centres served greater amounts of food than New Brunswick centres (p < 0.05). French-speaking centres provided less fat (p = 0.047), less saturated fat (p = 0.01), and fewer servings of meat and alternatives (p = 0.02), and more trans fat (p = 0.03) than English-speaking centres. There were no differences between rural and urban centres.CONCLUSIONS: Few CC lunches met nutritional recommendations. Interventions are required to improve the quality of foods offered in CCs. Reviewing or developing comprehensive nutrition guidelines is warranted.KEY WORDS: Child day care centers; food quality; lunch; nutritional value La traduction du résumé se trouve à la fin de l'article.

Fruit, Vegetable, and Fibre Intake among Finnish Preschoolers in Relation to Preschool-Level Facilitators and Barriers to Healthy Nutrition

“…There has been an increasing amount of research on the preschool environment and children’s food intake in recent years. Most of the factors under study relate directly to meal times, such as the (un)healthiness of the food served [5,6,7] and, to some extent, the feeding practices of the personnel [8,9,10,11]. Less attention has been given to other preschool-level factors that are more distal from meal times.…”

An Environmental Scan of Existing Canadian Childcare Resources Targeting Improvements in Health Behaviours

“…A main finding of the environmental scan is that there are ample high-quality Canadian childcare resources for nutrition and physical activity, with some of these resources targeting both behaviours. Childcare centres are in a unique position to impact the quality and variety of food children eat because snacks and lunches are often provided daily in many centres (Larson et al, 2011;Ward et al, 2017). Childcare regulations in most Canadian provinces and territories stipulate that the Canada Food Guide should be followed, though specific recommendations regarding food and beverages are rare (Vercammen et al, 2020).…”

Effectiveness of the Healthy Start-Départ Santé approach on physical activity, healthy eating and fundamental movement skills of preschoolers attending childcare centres: a randomized controlled trial

“…The ECCs' environment in which food is prepared and served, is influenced by provincial standards. Yet, the implementation of these standards in ECCs is limited by the lack of enforcement, [48] and their interpretation may vary as a function of the presence of a dedicated cook, access to fresh and affordable healthy food, and other contextual factors such as child care leadership and priorities, which are difficult to standardize, thus possibly explaining the modest direct impact on children's diet.…”