The quest for atomically
precise synthesis of colloidal semiconductor
nanostructures has attracted increasing attention in recent years
and remains a formidable challenge. Nevertheless, atomically precise
clusters of semiconductors, known as magic-size clusters (MSCs), are
readily accessible. Ultrathin one-dimensional nanowires and two-dimensional
nanoplatelets and nanosheets can also be categorized as magic-size
nanocrystals (MSNCs). Further, the magic-size growth regime has been
recently extended into the size range of colloidal QDs (up to 3.5
nm). Nevertheless, the underlying reasons for the enhanced stability
of magic-size nanostructures and their formation mechanisms remain
obscure. In this Perspective, we address these intriguing questions
by critically analyzing the currently available knowledge on the formation
and stability of both MSCs and MSNCs (0D, 1D, and 2D). We conclude
that research on magic-size colloidal nanostructures is still in its
infancy, and many fundamental questions remain unanswered. Nonetheless,
we identify several correlations between the formation of MSCs and
0D, 1D and 2D MSNSs. From our analysis, it appears that the “magic”
originates from the complexity of a dynamic and multivariate system
running under reaction control. Under conditions that impose a prohibitively
high energy barrier for classical nucleation and growth, the reaction
proceeds through a complex and dynamic potential landscape, searching
for the pathway with the lowest energy barrier, thereby sequentially
forming metastable products as it jumps from one local minimum to
the next until it eventually becomes trapped into a minimum that is
too deep with respect to the available thermal energy. The intricacies
of this complex interplay between several synergistic and antagonistic
processes are, however, not yet understood and should be further investigated
by carefully designed experiments combining multiple complementary
in situ characterization techniques.