Because the 1-40 Bridges over the Rio Grande were to be razed during the summer of 1993, the investigators were able to introduce damage into the structure in order to test various damage identification methods. To support this research effort, NMSU contracted Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) to perform experimental modal analyses, and to develop experimentally verified numerical models of the bridge. Previous reports (LA-12767-MS and LA-12979-MS) summarize the results of the experimental modal analyses and the results obtained from numerical modal analyses conducted with finite element models. This report summarizes the application of five damage identification algorithms reported in the technical literature to the previously reported experimental and numerical modal data.Damage or fault detection, as determined by changes in the dynamic properties or response of structures, is a subject which has received considerable attention in the technical literature beginning approximately 30 years ago, and with a significant increase in reported studies appearing during the last five years. The basic idea is that modal parameters, notably frequencies, mode shapes, and modal damping, are a function of the physical properties of the structure (mass, damping, stiffness, and boundary conditions). Therefore, changes in physical properties of the structure, such as its stiffness or flexibility, will cause changes in the modal properties. Early methods for detecting damage based on changes in the structure's dynamic properties primarily examined changes in the resonant frequencies. However, this parameter has proved to be insensitive to lower levels of damage and does not provide a means to locate the damage. Current methods that have shown promise in both detecting damage at an early stage and locating the damage examine changes in the mode shapes of the structure.The major contribution of this study is a direct comparison of five damage identification methods that were applied to the same experimental and numerical modal data. The experimental data were measured on an actual highway bridge. The numerical data was generated from finite element models of the same bridge that had been benchmarked against the measured response. With the numerical models many more damage scenarios could be investigated to further study the relative accuracy of the various damage identification methods. In all cases, the numerical studies were intended to simulate the measurement techniques that would be used if these methods were to be incorporated into an on-line monitoring system for highway bridges. This restriction implies that dynamic properties must be measured from ambient traffic-induced vibration sources.