Lower carbohydrate and higher fat intakes are associated with higher hemoglobin A1c: findings from the UK National Diet and Nutrition Survey 2008–2016

Abstract

Purpose Evidence of low-carbohydrate, high-fat diets (LCHF) for type 2 diabetes (T2DM) prevention is scarce. We investigated how carbohydrate intake relates to HbA1c and T2DM prevalence in a nationally representative survey dataset. Methods We analyzed dietary information (4-day food diaries) from 3234 individuals aged ≥ 16 years, in eight waves of the UK National Diet and Nutrition Survey (2008-2016). We calculated LCHF scores (0-20, higher score indicating lower %food energy from carbohydrate, with reciprocal higher contribution from fat) and UK Dietary Reference Value (DRV) scores (0-16, based on UK dietary recommendations). Associations between macronutrients and diet scores and diabetes prevalence were analyzed (in the whole sample) using multivariate logistic regression. Among those without diabetes, analyses between exposures and %HbA1c (continuous) were analyzed using multivariate linear regression. All analyses were adjusted for age, sex, body mass index, ethnicity, smoking status, total energy intake, socioeconomic status and survey years. Results In the overall study sample, 194 (6.0%) had diabetes. Mean intake was 48.0%E for carbohydrates, and 34.9%E for total fat. Every 5%E decrease in carbohydrate, and every 5%E increase in fat, was associated with 12% (95% CI 0.78-0.99; P = 0.03) and 17% (95% CI 1.02-1.33; P = 0.02) higher odds of diabetes, respectively. Each two-point increase in LCHF score is related to 8% (95% CI 1.02-1.14; P = 0.006) higher odds of diabetes, while there was no evidence for association between DRV score and diabetes. Among the participants without diagnosed diabetes (n = 3130), every 5%E decrease in carbohydrate was associated with higher %HbA1c by + 0.016% (95% CI 0.004-0.029; P = 0.012), whereas every 5%E increase in fat was associated with higher %HbA1c by + 0.029% (95% CI 0.015-0.043; P < 0.001). Each two-point increase in LCHF score is related to higher %HbA1c by + 0.010% (0.1 mmol/mol), while each two-point increase in the DRV score is related to lower %HbA1c by − 0.023% (0.23 mmol/mol). Conclusions Lower carbohydrate and higher fat intakes were associated with higher HbA1c and greater odds of having diabetes. These data do not support low(er) carbohydrate diets for diabetes prevention. Keywords Reduced carbohydrate diet • Carbohydrate-restricted diet • High-fat diet • Dietary recommendation • Glycated hemoglobin • Type 2 diabetes Abbreviations T2DM Type 2 diabetes LCHF Low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet NDNS National diet and nutrition survey DRV Dietary reference value NMES Non-milk extrinsic sugar NSP Non-starch polysaccharide BMI Body mass index NS-SEC National statistics socioeconomic classification Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (

Carbohydrate knowledge, dietary guideline awareness, motivations and beliefs underlying low-carbohydrate dietary behaviours

“…Respondents who had high knowledge about www.nature.com/scientificreports/ carbohydrates, and their role in nurition and health, were more concerned about the unfavourable consequences of LCDs on micronutrient inadequacy. Foods recommended in LCDs also conflict with dietary guidelines recommendations 25 . Compared to non-LCD followers, current followers consumed less starchy foods, fruits and vegetables, but more meat, fish, and cheese, similar to a previous study 21 .…”

“…Respondents who had high knowledge about carbohydrates, and their role in nurition and health, were more concerned about the unfavourable consequences of LCDs on micronutrient inadequacy. Foods recommended in LCDs also conflict with dietary guidelines recommendations 25 .…”

“…Poor or incomplete knowledge on the nutritional compositions of foods and the balance of an overall diet, coupled with incorrect beliefs about food and health, may put people who attempt to follow a LCD at risk if their diet is not guided professionally 1 , 23 , 24 . National dietary guidelines are compiled by independent scientific and medical experts, based on the totality of the nutritional evidence, and there is evidence that higher adherence to dietary guidelines is linked with a reduction in chronic disease risks 25 – 27 . Knowledge of guideline recommendations is intended to improve individuals’ food choices, but journalistic scepticism and a lack of understanding of scientific evidence can lead to inappropriate rejection of guidelines in many fields 28 , 29 .…”

Low and reduced carbohydrate diets: challenges and opportunities for type 2 diabetes management and prevention

“…Our cross-sectional analysis in people without known diabetes in the National Diet and Nutrition Survey in the UK showed that, although few people ( n 8 or 0⋅24 % of the overall sample) met the conservative definition of LCD (<26 % energy), both lower carbohydrate intake (per 5 % energy band) and LCD pattern (according to LCD adherence score), were associated with higher HbA1c (+0⋅16 mmol/mol, P = 0⋅012, per 5 % energy decrease in carbohydrate; +0⋅10 mmol/mol, P = 0⋅001, per 2-point increase in LCD adherence score) (138) . The National Diet and Nutrition Survey used food diaries for the estimation of dietary intakes, which are more accurate and less reliant on memories compared to the FFQ.…”

Telehealth coaching to improve self-management for secondary prevention after stroke: A randomized controlled trial of Stroke Coach

“…Furthermore, our finding may also be explained by the reduced fat consumption by individuals in Stroke Coach compared to Memory Training, considering evidence of an association between fat consumption and HbA1c. 32…”