Low self-concept in poor readers: prevalence, heterogeneity, and risk

Abstract

There is evidence that poor readers are at increased risk for various types of low self-concept—particularly academic self-concept. However, this evidence ignores the heterogeneous nature of poor readers, and hence the likelihood that not all poor readers have low self-concept. The aim of this study was to better understand which types of poor readers have low self-concept. We tested 77 children with poor reading for their age for four types of self-concept, four types of reading, three types of spoken language, and two types of attention. We found that poor readers with poor attention had low academic self-concept, while poor readers with poor spoken language had low general self-concept in addition to low academic self-concept. In contrast, poor readers with typical spoken language and attention did not have low self-concept of any type. We also discovered that academic self-concept was reliably associated with reading and receptive spoken vocabulary, and that general self-concept was reliably associated with spoken vocabulary. These outcomes suggest that poor readers with multiple impairments in reading, language, and attention are at higher risk for low academic and general self-concept, and hence need to be assessed for self-concept in clinical practice. Our results also highlight the need for further investigation into the heterogeneous nature of self-concept in poor readers.

Phonics training for English-speaking poor readers

“…Poor reading is associated with higher risk of school dropout (Daniel 2006), as well as anxiety, depression, low self-concept, and self-harm and suicide (Alexander-Passe 2015;Carroll 2006;Maughan 2003;McArthur 2016).…”

Maternal Stress and Coping Strategies in Developmental Dyslexia: An Italian Multicenter Study

“…In fact, DD is a complex neurodevelopmental deficit characterized by impaired reading acquisition despite the presence of adequate neurological and sensorial conditions, educational opportunities and normal cognitive level ( 2 ). Different cognitive and behavioral aspects are impaired in DD children such as sleep regulation ( 3 ), postural control ( 4 ), dental occlusion ( 5 ), mood regulation ( 6 ), and self-esteem ( 7 ). In this light, family support may be considered essential, particularly during the transition to adolescence and adulthood ( 8 ), and certainly relevant in pediatric age due to the natural frailty of this crucial period of life.…”

A better start to literacy learning: findings from a teacher-implemented intervention in children’s first year at school

“…Towards the end of their first year at school, children's reading performance predicted whether they had either positive or negative academic self-perception with over 70% accuracy. McArthur, Castles, Kohnen, and Banales (2016) reported that poor readers who also had poor foundational oral language skills were at particular risk for lower general self-concept and lower academic self-concept.…”