Love and compassion for the community: Emotions and practices among North Indian Muslims, c. 1870–1930

Abstract

This article investigates how philosophical and ethical reflections, rhetorical strategies, and emotional practices intersect. In the first section, it lays out the traditional emotion knowledge found in Persian and Indo-Persian texts on moral philosophy written in the Aristotelian tradition, which still held an important place in the education of people writing in and reading journals like Aligarh’s Tahzību-l Akhlāq. The second section looks at the transformation of this knowledge in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries and provides a close reading of texts that address education and self-education issues while simultaneously exhorting readers to feel more compassionate (and often to prove their compassion through specific actions). The last section, finally, uses the Punjabi traders of Delhi as a case study to show how practices of philanthropy contributed to community building. Compassion, the article argues, is a social emotion, but not necessarily an unequivocally benign emotion. It serves to construct a community and to negotiate its boundaries, but it is also a tool of exclusion and helps fortifying the communities’ internal hierarchies. The perception of the pain of others is as unequally distributed as the practices for its alleviation.

Revisiting space and emotion: New ways to study buildings and feelings

“…542-6) two-sided analysis: she, for example, reads maps as both positivist, physical realities and constructed visions of the world, and an analytical combination of both aspects allows for studies of 'space as a material reality and as the result of an antecedent and ongoing cultural interpretation.' While we agree with her innovative analysis of visual sources and general call for broader archival reference points, her examples tend to privilege archival material created by, often colonial, elites (Pernau, 2014(Pernau, , 2015a(Pernau, , 2015b(Pernau, , 2017. In this way, the desire to interrogate the co-dependency between space and emotion is limited because it still prioritises the emotional regimes projected by the elite instead of questioning the experiences of the everyday and the ordinary.…”

“…The conceptual and methodological marriage of urban history approaches and history of emotion frameworks, which was suggested by Pernau (2014; Pernau, 2015b) in this journal nine years ago, allows for a more holistic study of the relationship between bodies, urban spaces, and emotions. It provides insight into how emotions affect the built environment and how the built environment in turn enforces or changes emotions.…”

Beyond Discrimination: Aspirations for Self-employment Among Muslim Youth in Delhi

“…Some respondents in Jamia Nagar narrated that Muslims live in segregated spaces that make their social networks (Lin 1999 ) for employment limited to only those areas. These social networks were of two types, friendship networks and connections among youth highlighted in the works of Jeffrey 2010 , Nisbett ( 2007 ) and specifically among Muslims in the works of Osella ( 2012 ), Pernau ( 2017 ), and Chambers ( 2020 ). The second were family networks, capital, and strategies highlighted in the works of Ball ( 2003 ), Beteille ( 1991 ), Devine ( 2004 ), and Donner ( 2008 ).…”

Emotions and Temporalities

“…If only men felt strongly, they would still prevent their race from dying (Sanyasi, 1926), not only because their motivation would push them to action and sacrifice, but also because redemption, at both the individual and communal levels, lay in the emotions themselves, in their very intensity even before their actual content. Nevertheless, a number of emotions were central to arousing this fervor: anger against the oppressor; the heteroerotic love for the homeland, imagined as female (Najmabadi, 2005;Ramaswamy, 2010); the fraternal love among sons of the same mother; and compassion for all members of the community, including notably its weaker sections (Pernau, 2017).…”