Loss of species richness with land use intensity is explained by a reduction in niche differences

Abstract

Increases in land use intensity (LUI) reduce species richness. However, we have a poor understanding of how underlying coexistence mechanisms are altered by land use and whether diversity loss occurs due to changes in plant-plant interactions (competition and facilitation) or in species intrinsic growth rates. We expect that LUI could reduce stabilizing niche differences and the indirect interactions that promote coexistence (e.g., intransitivity), while increasing competitive inequalities between species. To test the importance of these different processes, we use 8-yr time series from 150 grasslands differing in LUI to evaluate the role of direct and indirect interactions in promoting coexistence between 50 plant species. We show that LUI reduces the number of coexisting species mostly by causing a non-linear reduction in niche differences, rather than by enhancing competitive inequalities. However, surprisingly, niche differences remained important in stabilizing coexistence between those species remaining at high LUI. Indirect interactions were generally less important than direct ones, and played a moderate role in promoting coexistence in smaller assemblages of species at intermediate LUI. Our models could accurately reproduce the decline in diversity seen with LUI, indicating that our time series approach captures the important interactions between species. By analyzing land use effects through recent advances in structural stability applied to community ecology we provide a more mechanistic understanding of its effects. Our results highlight the importance of identifying the niche differences that are lost with increasing LUI, to better predict and manage effects of land use on biodiversity.