Loop migration in adult marsh harriers Circus aeruginosus, as revealed by satellite telemetry

Abstract

Loop migration among birds is characterized by the spring route lying consistently west or east of the autumn route. The existence of loops has been explained by general wind conditions or seasonal differences in habitat distribution. Loop migration has predominantly been studied at the population level, for example by analysing ring recoveries. Here we study loop migration of individual marsh harriers Circus aeruginosus tracked by satellite telemetry. We show that despite a generally narrow migration corridor the harriers travelled in a distinct clockwise loop through Africa and southern Europe, following more westerly routes in spring than in autumn. We used the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to identify potential feeding habitat in Africa. Suitable habitat seemed always more abundant along the western route, both in spring and autumn, and no important stopover site was found along the eastern route. Observed routes did thus not coincide with seasonal variation in habitat availability. However, favourable habitat might be more important during spring migration, when the crossing of the Sahara seems more challenging, and thus habitat availability might play an indirect role in the harriers' route choice. Grid-based wind data were used to reconstruct general wind patterns, and in qualitative agreement with the observed loop marsh harriers predominantly encountered westerly winds in Europe and easterly winds in Africa, both in autumn and in spring. By correlating tail-and crosswinds with forward and perpendicular movement rates, respectively, we show that marsh harriers are partially drifted by wind. Thus, we tentatively conclude that wind rather than habitat seems to have an overriding effect on the shape of the migration routes of marsh harriers. General wind conditions seem to play an important role also in the evolution of narrow migratory loops as demonstrated for individual marsh harriers.

Population‐level scaling of avian migration speed with body size and migration distance for powered fliers

“…For example, we can now observe broadscale divergence in migration patterns, which can add to our current understanding of how phenotypes are structured at macro scales (Jetz et al 2009) and the role of migration in structuring avian evolution. In addition, hypotheses that address observed variation in migratory patterns can be tested from a broader perspective; e.g., the role of atmospheric conditions and stopover habitat as factors responsible for defining seasonal variation in migration routes that results in looped trajectories (Klaassen et al 2010). Building on these examples, an improved understanding of the spatiotemporal structure and drivers of migration at macro scales can better inform conservation strategies directed toward the broadscale maintenance of genetic diversity and the quality of stopover habitats.…”

Geographical and temporal flexibility in the response to crosswinds by migrating raptors

“…For birds, geographical wind patterns have a most important effect on the evolution of migration routes [9][10][11][12]. However, little is known about how individual birds respond to lateral wind drift during migration (reviews in [2,5,13]).…”

The Spring Migration of Adult North American Ospreys

“…Although most published studies of bird migration have focused on fall, some studies have presented spring migration data and compared the details of spring vs. fall migration (e.g., Klaassen et al 2010). Martell et al (2004) reported on spring and fall migration of seven ospreys that migrated from Florida to South America and Alerstam et al (2006) found differences in spring and fall migration strategies among seven Ospreys tagged in Sweden.…”