“Looking at Myself in the Future”: how mentoring shapes scientific identity for STEM students from underrepresented groups

Abstract

Background Mentorship has been well-established in the literature as fostering scientific identity and career pathways for underrepresented minority students in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. Mentorship is prioritized by programs that aim to increase diversity and support future leadership in STEM fields, but in-depth understanding of mentorship in these contexts remains limited. Drawing on qualitative interview data, we sought to understand the relationship between mentoring and scientific identity among a diverse sample of 24 students in one such program, in order to inform program development. Results Qualitative analysis of the data revealed that mentorship, especially research mentorship, was common and played a role in formation of scientific identity. Students with research mentors tended to say they strongly identified as scientists, whereas those who lacked research mentorship varied in their level of scientific identity. In interviews, research-mentored students described mentors as colleagues who gave them opportunities to grow and as examples to look up to. Students valued mentors with whom they identified on the basis of demographic similarity or shared values, as well as those who challenged them in their academic and research endeavors. Conclusions Our analysis highlights how different mentoring experiences can contribute to development of future STEM leadership. We discuss implications for practice, including the need for tailored mentoring approaches and research-focused mentoring, and offer several recommendations for research and programming.

Increasing STEM Transfer Readiness Among Underrepresented Minoritized Two-Year College Students: Examining Course-Taking Patterns, Experiences, and Interventions

“…Supporting ISP participants' STEM identity was done through holistic faculty mentoring, career presentations led by STEM professionals of color, and engaging the peer guides (participants that had already successfully transferred into STEM) to work with the participants. Requiring participants to develop and staff STEM outreach activities also allowed them to strengthen their STEM identity (Atkins et al, 2020). Another support for students was in the curricular momentum domain in the form of opportunities for tutoring and academic support from peers utilizing the peer tutors in the ISP and regular, required group study sessions (study jams) held in the STEM Center.…”

Improving Academic Performance and Retention of First-Year Biology Students through a Scalable Peer Mentorship Program

“…Extant literature on mentored research experiences has demonstrated evidence on the importance of aligning menteementor demographics or values (Blake-Beard et al, 2007, 2011Terrion and Leonard, 2007;Hernandez et al, 2016Hernandez et al, , 2017Atkins et al, 2020). Given the rapid proliferation of peer mentorship interventions across postsecondary educational settings, these programs provide a diversity of contexts that will enable dissection of how alignment of various mentor-mentee values and demographics influence the effectiveness of these approaches.…”

Virtual Vanderbilt Summer Science Academy highlighted the opportunity to impact early STEMM students career knowledge through narrative

“…Beyond opportunity, students lower in social status may also experience rejection sensitivity in evaluative assessment situations that emphasis rank and status, so increasing opportunity can help beyond simply providing experience [ 16 ]. In order to increase the representation of underrepresented and disadvantaged students, exposure to the STEMM community and a diverse array of mentoring experiences are necessarily [ 17 ]. The goal of the program was to break preconceived notions that individuals who pursue postgraduate training are highly homogeneous and instead demonstrate the diversity of the community in order to increase participant’s own sense of identity and belonging to STEMM.…”