Long-term psychological recovery process and its associated factors among survivors of the Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake in Japan: a qualitative study

Abstract

ObjectivesThe 1995 Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake had an enormous negative impact on survivors’ health. Many survivors experienced psychological distress and their long-term psychological recovery process remains unclear. Our objective was thus to explore this long-term psychological recovery process.DesignQualitative study.SettingFrom January to December 2015, face-to-face interviews were conducted in Kobe, Japan.Participants20 affected survivors (55% female; ages ranged from 7 to 60 at the time of the disaster)—10 volunteer storytellers, six first responders (firefighters/public health nurses) and four post-traumatic stress disorder patients.Outcome measuresWe asked participants about their experiences and psychological distress relating to the earthquake and what facilitated or hindered their psychological recovery. We analysed interview data using constructivist grounded theory.ResultsParticipants experienced diverse emotional reactions immediately after the disaster and often hyperfocused on what they should do now. This hyperfocused state led to both mental and physical health problems several months after the disaster. Months, and sometimes years, after the disaster, guilt and earthquake narratives (ie, expressing thoughts and feelings about the earthquake) played key roles in survivors’ psychological recovery: guilt suppressed their earthquake narrative; conversely, the narrative alleviated feelings of distress about the earthquake. In time, participants reconsidered their earthquake experiences both alone and through social interaction. This alleviated their emotional reactions; however, participants still experienced attenuated emotional reactions, and some hid their feelings of distress even 20 years postdisaster. Interpersonal relationships modified this psychological process both positively and negatively.ConclusionsFuture psychosocial support plans for disaster survivors may need to (1) include both mental and physical care in the transition from the acute phase to the recovery phase; (2) facilitate supportive interpersonal relationships for survivors during the mid-term recovery phase and (3) provide long-term psychological support to the most traumatised survivors, even if they appear to be functioning normally.

The Relationship Among Rumination, Coping Strategies, and Subjective Well-being in Chinese Patients With Breast Cancer: A Cross-sectional study

“…In 2004, Tedeschi et al [9] proposed the concept and model of post-traumatic growth (PTG), which stimulated the study of positive psychology in BC patients. Tanaka et al [10] found that people with traumatic experiences and higher levels of well-being were more likely to have positive thoughts than people with lower levels of well-being. Nevertheless, the definition and strategies to achieve well-being are still under debate.…”

Changes in Japanese Junior High School Students' Sense of Coherence Before and After the Onset of the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Longitudinal Study of Children and Mothers

“…This is similar to when the residents of Japan experienced the shock of “suddenly changing their ordinary lives 1 day at a time” when an unprecedented earthquake called the Great East Japan Earthquake struck Japan in 2011. During that time, people also realized how dear everyday life was ( 34 ). In the current case, experiencing the pandemic, school closures, and resumption of school due to COVID-19 may have reaffirmed the joy of going to school every day' among the students.…”

Earthquakes

“…The most widespread and enduring impact will be the psychological stress and posttraumatic stress resulting from fear, anxiety over the loss of housing and services, and exposure to devastation and injuries of loved ones and community members (Dai et al, 2016;Farooqui et al, 2017). It is one of the most underestimated and persistent needs following a disaster and is often not addressed due to a lack of understanding the long-term impacts and a lack of sufficient resources at the local level (Alisha et al, 2019;Tanaka et al, 2019). Following the 2010 earthquake in Chile, government and health officials told a visiting Red Cross delegation that their greatest need for healthcare was behavioral health.…”