Long-term mentoring relationships in undergraduate longitudinal general practice tracks – a qualitative study on the perspective of students and general practitioners

Abstract

Background Longitudinal general practice tracks have been established in medical faculties in Europe and worldwide to attract more graduates to general practice careers. In many programs, long-term mentoring relationships play an important role in providing students with positive role models, regular practical experiences, and acquisition of clinical skills in a community context. However, little is known about students’ and general practitioner mentors’ expectations, experiences, challenges, and ideas for improvement within these long-term mentoring relationships in general practice in our medical education system. Methods Qualitative study based on semi-structured interviews with 15 students and 13 mentors. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. MAXQDA was used for data analysis, following a mixed deductive/inductive approach. Results Both groups had few and rather unstated expectations, particularly regarding their relationships. Consequently, expectations were often not clearly communicated. Nevertheless, a high level of satisfaction and good opportunities for teaching were achieved for both sides. The evolving familiarity facilitated a positive learning environment. Students valued independent medical tasks continuously adjusted to their current abilities. However, some felt a reluctance to demand their mentor’s time and consideration. Conversely, the mentors criticized a lack of initiative from some of the students and wished that they would get more actively involved. Students, in contrast, wished for more guidance at the start of the project and joint events to deepen the relationship. Conclusions With this study, we gained detailed insights into and understanding of the nature of long-term relationships between students and mentors. Points for improvement revealed included: 1) education of both participating groups on the goals and benefits of mentoring, including binding expectations for the participants; 2) intensified support and training of teaching physicians; 3) structured and accompanied establishment of initial contact between mentor and mentee; and 4) encouraged additional shared (teaching) time, individualized timing, and intensification, if desired.

Support, networks, and relationships: Findings from a mixed-methods evaluation of a mentorship programme for early career women researchers in sexual and reproductive health and rights

“…Similarly, others have also shown that mentees value mentors' support to their work-life balance which came through in this evaluation [39]. Furthermore, much of the literature focuses on the importance of having a caring and supportive relationship where guidance and communication are key, similarly to what we found in this evaluation [39,45]. However, the HRP Alliance mentorship programme had a very specific aim of providing support and skills development as part of researchers' professional development, but which did not include a specific output or development of research skills.…”

Attitudes toward depression among rural primary healthcare providers in hunan areas, China: a cross sectional study

“…Building efficient information systems for accessing psychotherapeutic medicines timely, collaborating with psychologists and psychiatrists, and sharing the experience on screening, diagnosis, and treatment of common mental disorders were effective [ 22 , 26 ]. In medical education, long-term mentoring was widely applied and showed a good effect on independent medical tasks, and enabled mentors to provide guidance, resources, encouragement, constructive criticism, and support to their mentees [ 36 ]. A whole-course mentoring system, in which mentors summarize and solve the main problems during the standardized training, could improve self-efficacy and job satisfaction for graduated nurses [ 37 ].…”

Missing topics for a newly established general practice curriculum for medical students in Hesse – a qualitative study

“…Moreover, similar to the suggestion in literature (6), it was emphasized that the implementation of role models and personal insights help increase attractivity of general practice to students. Other recommendations -like the importance of a long-term one-to-one mentoring program (19) or the integration of a teaching app (10) -were not mentioned in our interviews. A new insight is the demand for new teaching methods such as symptom-based learning, lessons with simulated patients and the integration of case reports.…”