Long-term field experiments in Germany: classification and spatial representation

Abstract

Abstract. The collective analysis of long-term field experiments (LTFEs), here defined as agricultural experiments with a minimum duration of 20 years and research in the context of sustainable soil use and yield, can be used for detecting changes in soil properties and yield such as those induced by climate change. However, information about existing LTFEs is scattered, and the research data are not easily accessible. In this study, meta-information on LTFEs in Germany is compiled and their spatial representation is analyzed. The study is conducted within the framework of the BonaRes project, which, inter alia, has established a central access point for LTFE information and research data. A total of 205 LTFEs which fit to the definition above are identified. Of these, 140 LTFEs are ongoing. The land use in 168 LTFEs is arable field crops, in 34 trials grassland, in 2 trials vegetables and in 1 trial pomiculture. Field crop LTFEs are categorized into fertilization (n=158), tillage (n=38) and crop rotation (n=32; multiple nominations possible) experiments, while all grassland experiments (n=34) deal with fertilization. The spatial representation is analyzed according to the climatic water balance of the growing season (1 May to 31 October) (CWBg), the Müncheberg Soil Quality Rating (MSQR) and clay content. The results show that, in general, the LTFEs well represent the area shares of both the CWBg and the MSQR classes. Eighty-nine percent of the arable land and 65 % of the grassland in Germany are covered by the three driest CWBg classes, hosting 89 % and 71 % of the arable and grassland LTFEs, respectively. LTFEs cover all six MSQR classes but with a bias towards the high and very high soil quality classes. LTFEs on arable land are present in all clay content classes according to the European Soil Data Centre (ESDAC) but with a bias towards the clay content class 4. Grassland LTFEs show a bias towards the clay content classes 5, 6 and 7, while well representing the other clay content classes, except clay content class 3, where grassland LTFEs are completely missing. The results confirm the very high potential of LTFE data for spatially differentiated analyses and modeling. However, reuse is restricted by the difficult access to LTFE research data. The common database is an important step in overcoming this restriction.

Functional Multi‐Scale Integration of Agricultural Nitrogen‐Budgets Into Catchment Water Quality Modeling

“…Therefore, conventional catchment model calibration is unlikely to be able to constrain $${\bar{P}}_{uptk}$$ uncertainty, nor to reflect its changes under different management practices. We made use of extensively available local fertilization experimental data in agricultural research (Grosse et al., 2020; Körschens et al., 2013). The measured actual uptake exhibited interannual variations (Figure 1), presumably due to climatic variability, crop variety changes, and specific differences of management practices and pest controls during the long‐term experiments.…”

Provision of metadata of European agricultural long-term experiments through BonaRes and EJP SOIL collaboration

“…All templates that passed the automatic review were merged together to form the final database. The database was then exported to the format described above to be further processed and merged with datasets [1 , 3 , 4] .…”

“…The dataset comprises an updated number of the LTEs and revised research categories compared to the data published by Grosse et al. [1 , 3] . Recently the complete dataset consists of metadata for 616 LTEs from 30 countries in Europe ( Fig.…”

Reanalysis in Earth System Science: Toward Terrestrial Ecosystem Reanalysis

“…The key processes in carbon cycle models have been studied at various scales by networks of eddy covariance measurements (i.e., FLUXNET, Papale et al, 2006;Reichstein et al, 2007), field experiments (Chabbi et al, 2017;Grosse et al, 2020) and ecosystem manipulations simulating for example, atmospheric carbon dioxide enrichment (Ainsworth & Long, 2005;Wieder et al, 2019). However, the terrestrial carbon cycle remains poorly constrained, with uncertain interactions and feedbacks (e.g., Friedlingstein et al, 2014;Huntzinger et al, 2017).…”