To study how wildlife perceive recreational users, we studied the habitat selection of a human commensalist, the collared peccary (Pecari tajacu (Linnaeus, 1758)). We measured peccary activity patterns in a high-human-activity area (Tumamoc Hill Desert Laboratory in Tucson, Arizona) using a landscape of fear analysis. We examined whether the perception of risk from human activity interacted with the anti-predator mechanisms of local plant species, in both chemical (tannin) and mechanical (thorns). The peccaries avoided food stations near a hiking trail. The population foraged less near houses, i.e. moderate human activity, than in the perceived safety of a small wadi. Plant defense treatments impacted the harvesting of food only in the safe zone, suggesting that risk trumps food selectivity. The strong effect of the hiking trail on habitat selection in this disturbance-loving species is an indicator of a much larger impact on sensitive species in conservation areas.