Long-standing Continuous Unemployment in Male Patients with Psychiatric Symptoms

Hall, P.; Tonge, W. L.

doi:10.1136/jech.17.4.191

Cited by 2 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 10 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…As a psychiatrist trained in Manchester, Lawton studied the problem of maladjustment as the cause of unemployment in men (Markowe et al, 1955a(Markowe et al, , 1955bHall and Tonge, 1963) and the incidence of neuroses among women (Tonge et al, 1961). 9 Here Tonge was part of a wider trend which interpreted improper adjustment to modern society as something within the individual and reflected in 'symptoms' evident to the expert.…”

Section: William Lawton Tonge and Families Without Hopementioning

confidence: 99%

In pursuit of "the welfare trait": recycling deprivation and reproducing depravation in historical context

Lambert¹

2016

PPP

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Adam Perkins' The Welfare Trait outlines the most recent attempt to provide substance to the existence of an underclass, based on the idea of a shared 'welfare-induced', 'employment-resistant' personality amongst benefit claimants. Following in the footsteps of historian John Macnicol who went 'in pursuit' of the underclass, this article travels 'in pursuit' of the welfare trait by situating its claims in historical context through a comparison of the post-war study by William Tonge, Families without Hope, which sought to identify a common psychological maladjustment in 'problem families.' The common intention, methods and recommendations of the two studies underline their shared purpose: to transfer the social and policy problems associated with poverty from their socio-economic context and the culpabilities of the state to finding the problem in individual families, identifying their behaviour as problematic and proscribing solutions rooted around cultivating personal responsibility.

show abstract