Local collective action for sustainability transformations: emerging narratives from local energy initiatives in The Netherlands

Abstract

The phrase “local collective action” is increasingly being used to describe how civil society engages with, and acts upon, sustainability transformations. While existing research has framed local collective action as an outcome of creating a shared agenda on a local level, there have been calls for exploring the diversity of ideas, motives, and ambitions people have when they join local energy initiatives. This article aims to identify the diverse attitudes towards local collective action envisioned by those who engage in local energy initiatives. We use Q methodology to analyze people’s perceptions of the local collective action they are engaged in and how those perceptions could manifest in different pathways for sustainability transformations. Forty-seven statements reflecting various approaches to local collective action were sorted by people engaged in various local energy initiatives in the northeast of the Netherlands. Based on the analysis, we distinguish four factors—Localism, Facilitation, Orchestration, and Radical Transformation—that express the diverse aspirations, motivations, and rationales associated with local collective action in local energy initiatives. The findings emphasize that for those engaged in local energy initiatives (LEIs), local collective action means navigating among different assumptions, values, and transformation processes, which often oscillate between guiding principles that emphasize “getting things done” and “creating a pleasant atmosphere”. We argue that these four factors can serve as a starting point for developing local collective action strategies to help local communities and authorities unpack possible tensions, confrontations, and conflicts concerning local energy initiatives. These findings point out that while local energy initiatives rely on people’s energy and enthusiasm, practitioners and governments should be cautious while embracing their ambitions and values.

From “Putting the Last First” to “Working with People” in Rural Development Planning: A Bibliometric Analysis of 50 Years of Research

“…Local collective action is increasingly being used to describe how civil society engages with, and acts upon, sustainability transformations. The findings emphasise that "working with people"-in several experiences in rural development projects-means navigating among different assumptions, values, and social transformation processes, which involve guiding principles as "local collective action" [99], "putting the last first" [43], "Putting people first" [46] and "planning as social learning" [23]. This evidence appears both in the literature review, with its heterogeneous results, and the keyword analysis.…”

Tipologías de la gobernanza territorial en la pesca de langosta espinosa en las reservas de la biósfera de Sian Ka'an y Banco Chinchorro, Quintana Roo, México

“…En la investigación estudiamos tres formas de innovaciones socioambientales en los territorios: a) las innovaciones desde abajo surgen a partir de las acciones colectivas que emprenden los actores en un contexto territorial particular para resolver problemas que afectan el desarrollo cotidiano de las actividades productivas en sus comunidades (Rodima-Taylor, 2012;Helmsing y Enzama, 2016;Hasanov y Zuidema, 2022); b) las innovaciones verticales/jerárquicas se refieren a políticas instrumentadas por instancias gubernamentales, mediante la imposición de medidas de manejo de recursos o conservación ambiental que los actores locales debieran acatar (Torres et al, 2017); y c) las innovaciones multi-escalares se refieren a las iniciativas de conservación y/o certificación ambiental que se instrumentan con la participación de actores en distintas escalas, para promover prácticas sustentables de pesca y la inserción de los pescadores en redes de comercio más benéficas (Bush y Oosterveer, 2019).…”

The Impact of China’s National Sustainable Development Experimental Zone Policy on Energy Transition

“…The World Energy Council (WEC) defines energy transition as a fundamental change in the energy structure caused by an increase in the share of renewable energy and the phasing out of fossil fuels. At present, policy [27,28], innovation [29,30], the market [10,31], and behavior [32] are the main drivers of energy transition in countries around the world. Unlike the previous two energy transitions driven by technological progress, policy is the starting point of the third energy transition.…”