Liquidity Management of Indian Cement Companies – A Comparative Study

Abstract

Liquidity management is a concept that is gaining serious attention all over the world because of the current financial turmoil and the state of the world economy. The concern of business owners and managers all over the world is to devise a strategy which will help in maintaining liquidity as well as to increase profitability and shareholder's wealth. Liquidity is perceived as the debt paying ability of a going concern. It is the ability of a company to meet the short term obligations. Hence, it is of utmost important to keep a constant eye on liquidity position of the company as without it the company cannot survive. In this paper a comparative study on the liquidity position of five leading Indian cement companies has been done to know the liquidity position of the companies. The study covers a period of 10 years viz, 2000-2001 to 2009-2010. For the purpose of investigation purely secondary data is used. The techniques of mean, standard deviation, coefficient of variation, ratio analysis, and Motaal's ultimate rank test has been applied to analyse the data. It has been found that the liquidity position of small companies are better as compared to big ones and most interestingly the growth rate of current ratio, quick ratio and working capital to current assets of all the companies are negative which indicates an unsound liquidity position. Moreover, low or negative working capital in some cases indicates the aggressive working capital management policy of the firms which implies minimal investment in current assets by the companies so as to derive a higher rate of return. But it has to be remembered that risk of default and bankruptcy increases when a firm adopts more aggressive working capital policies. One should remember that a negative working capital is a sign of managerial efficiency in a business with low inventory and accounts receivable (which means they operate on an almost strictly cash basis). In any other situation, it is a sign that a company may be facing bankruptcy or serious financial trouble. In our case, Motaal's Ultimate Rank Test shows that the liquidity position of Shree Cements is sounder as compared to other companies.

The Impact of Liquidity on Firms’ Performance: Empirical Investigation from Indian Pharmaceutical Companies

“…On the other hand, (Bhunia, Khan, & MuKhuti, 2011;Krishnakumar, 2010;Panigrahi, 2013) applied their research in Indian software, cement and steel sectors respectively using traditional indices for measuring liquidity and different measures for profitability such as return on Investment, gross Profit ratio, return on assets and earning per share, findings of these three studies found a negative association between liquidity and profitability. (Morgheim, 2015;Owolabi et al, 2011;Rehman, Khan, & Khokhar, 2015) conducted their research in America, Nigeria and Saudi Arabia respectively, they argued that there is a negative association between liquidity measured by traditional indices and profitability of firms.…”

tradeoff between liquidity and profitability: evidence from Indian manufacturing firms

“…This investigation has shown to be quite beneficial in establishing a link between "liquidity and profitability". However, while Panigrahi (2013) and Krishnakumar (2010) researched India's software, cement, and steel industries using both "traditional liquidity indices and alternative profitability metrics such as return on investment, gross profit margin, return on assets, and earnings per share", Bhunia et al (2011) and Panigrahi (2013) instead performed their research in these industries using both "the liquidity ratios metrics and alternative profitability metrics such as return on investment, gross profit margin, return on assets, and earnings per share". Findings were consistent with the notion that lower liquidity was correlated with lower profitability.…”

A Comparative Analysis of Liquidity and Profitability Position of Astral Poly Technik Ltd. and Finolex Industries Ltd. in India

“…Motaal prescribes a comprehensive test for determining the soundness of a company as regards liquidity position 6 .…”