The performance of silicon carbide as an alternative plasma facing material (PFM) was studied at various irradiation conditions relevant to ion energies and fluxes of a fusion reactor. This analysis involves detailed modeling of subsurface plasma/material interactions, sputtered particle transport above the surface and redeposition, and related changes in material composition and microstructure induced by steady-state and Edge Localized Mode ion fluxes. Transition of a crystalline SiC surface to semi-crystalline and amorphous phases was analyzed based on advanced modeling of DIII-D tokamak experiments where SiC was irradiated in single- and multiple- L-mode and H-mode discharges. This analysis shows that displacement damage, particle deposition/redeposition, and D accumulation on the SiC divertor surface can lead to significant microstructural changes that result in enhanced sputtering erosion in comparison with the original crystalline material. However, the resulting total net erosion rate for a full-coverage, advanced tokamak, SiC coated divertor may well be acceptably low. Moreover, the C sputtering yield from the evolved SiC surface can be seven times lower than from a pure graphite surface; this would imply significantly reduced tritium co-deposition rates in a D-T tokamak reactor, compared with a pure carbon surface. It was also determined that chemical sputtering of both C and Si should not result in any noticeable effect on the net erosion, for attached plasma regimes. Our results thus show encouraging results overall for use of SiC as a PFM in tokamaks.