“…In [20], the authors prove that such solutions are unstable on R 2 and in [22], the authors study the stability of these solutions in terms of an anisotropy parameter M , the disc radius R and specific values of β in (68). We do not make specific comparisons to the results in [20,22] because M = 0 in our case and our domain is a re-scaled annulus (not a disc) with a dimensionless geometrical parameter ρ. More generally, we note that solutions of the form Q = u(x, y)E 1 + w(x, y)E 2 + v(x, y)E 5 have been studied in [6] as minimizers of the Landau-de Gennes energy on 2D bounded simply-connected domains, Ω, for topologically non-trivial Dirichlet conditions in the limit of vanishing elastic constant.…”