Linking habitat suitability to demography in a pond-breeding amphibian

Abstract

IntroductionElucidating the relationship between habitat characteristics and population parameters is critical for effective conservation. Habitat suitability index (HSI) models are often used in wildlife management and conservation practice assuming that they predict species occurrence, abundance and demography. However, the relationship between vital rates such as survival and reproduction and habitat suitability has rarely been evaluated. In this study, we used pond occupancy and mark-recapture data to test whether HSI predicts occupancy, reproduction and survival probabilities. Our model species is the great crested newt (Triturus cristatus), a pond-breeding amphibian protected under the European Habitats Directive.ResultsOur results show a positive relationship between the HSI and reproduction probability, whereas pond occupancy and survival probabilities were not related to HSI. Mortality was found to be higher during breeding seasons when newts are in ponds than during terrestrial phases of adult newts.ConclusionHabitat suitability models are increasingly applied to wildlife management and conservation practice. We found that the HSI model predicted reproduction probability, rather than occurrence or survival. If HSI models indicate breeding populations rather than mere species occurrences, they may be used to identify habitats of higher priority for conservation. Future HSI models might be improved through modelling breeding populations vs. non-breeding populations rather than presence/absence data. However, according to our results the most suitable habitat is not necessarily the habitat where demographic performance is best. We recommend that conservation practitioners should use HSI models cautiously because there may be no direct link between habitat suitability, demography and consequently, population viability.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12983-015-0103-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Does movement behaviour predict population densities? A test with 25 butterfly species

“…; Unglaub et al . ), high population densities are assumed to reflect higher quality patches, and the causal relationships are similar to the diffusion‐density relationship we observe: higher resource density leads to slower movement, which leads to higher densities of foraging organisms. In other cases, high population density reflects lower per‐capita habitat quality and higher movement rates; this pattern has been documented by manipulating habitat quality and density in experimental populations (Kuefler, Avgar & Fryxell ).…”

Remotely sensed forest understory density and nest predator occurrence interact to predict suitable breeding habitat and the occurrence of a resident boreal bird species

“…This evaluation is crucial, because HSMs can only be used for management recommendations if they can be applied on a larger scale (Graf, Mathys, & Bollmann, ; Rechsteiner et al, ). While Rittenhouse et al () and Unglaub et al () evaluated occupancy‐based HSMs based on predictability of independently collected demographic rates, our study uses the opposite approach: We show how independently collected occupancy data can evaluate demographic rates based on a predicted HSM.…”

Avian SDMs: current state, challenges, and opportunities

“…Results are still inconsistent across studies (Bean et al 2014, Unglaub et al 2015, but there is an increasing number of examples in birds, where environmental suitability derived from SDMs correlates with other population parameters such as breeding density, territory size, or survival (Table 1). More research is needed on whether the observed correlations can be generalized and identified as causative across birds and whether dynamic distribution models (i.e.…”