RNA cleavage by RNA polymerase (RNAP) is the central step in co-transcriptional RNA proofreading. Bacterial RNAPs were proposed to rely on the same mobile element of the active site, the trigger loop (TL), for both nucleotide addition and RNA cleavage. RNA cleavage can also be stimulated by universal Gre factors, which should replace the TL to get access to the RNAP active site. The contributions of the TL and Gre factors to RNA cleavage reportedly vary between RNAPs from different bacterial species and, probably, different types of transcription complexes. Here, by comparing RNAPs from Escherichia coli, Deinococcus radiodurans, and Thermus aquaticus, we show that the functions of the TL and Gre factors in RNA cleavage are conserved in various species, with important variations that may be related to extremophilic adaptation. Deletions of the TL strongly impair intrinsic RNA cleavage by all three RNAPs and eliminate the interspecies differences in the reaction rates. GreA factors activate RNA cleavage by wild-type RNAPs to similar levels. The rates of GreA-dependent cleavage are lower for ⌬TL RNAP variants, suggesting that the TL contributes to the Gre function. Finally, neither the TL nor GreA can efficiently activate RNA cleavage in certain types of backtracked transcription complexes, suggesting that these complexes adopt a catalytically inactive conformation probably important for transcription regulation.The RNA cleavage reaction is thought to play a crucial role in correction of transcriptional errors during RNA synthesis by RNAP 2 (1-4). Because this reaction is performed by the same active site of RNAP as nucleotide addition, RNAP must "backtrack" along the DNA template after nucleotide misincorporation to allow cleavage of internal phosphodiester bonds in RNA. Long backtracking events can result in permanent stalling of RNAP in the backtracked state, and RNA cleavage also serves for reactivation of such "arrested" transcription elongation complexes (TECs) (5-7). After backtracking, the RNA 3Ј-end is accommodated within the secondary RNAP channel, which normally serves for NTP entry (Fig. 1). Both nucleotide addition and RNA cleavage require two divalent metal ions (usually Mg 2ϩ ) bound in the RNAP active site, which coordinate the reaction substrates (3,8). In addition to metal ions, several other factors were shown to contribute to RNA cleavage. In particular, the reaction is greatly stimulated by RNA nucleotide at position ϩ2 relative to the active site through its direct interactions with the second metal ion and the attacking water molecule (1). The ϩ2 nucleotide was also proposed to stimulate the second metal ion binding by changing the geometry of the active site residues involved in metal chelation ("active site tuning") (3). Recent crystallographic analysis of a bacterial backtracked TEC revealed that the ϩ2 RNA nucleotide is accommodated in an evolutionary conserved RNAP cavity ("proofreading site"), which facilitates catalysis (Fig. 1, left) (9). Similarly, interactions of the ϩ2 nucleotide i...