“…Ligule ontogeny is also dissimilar between Selaginella and Isoetes. In Selaginella the ligule develops from two rows of superficial cells (Smith, 1900a;Horner et al, 1975;Gifford and Foster, 1989), whereas the Isoetes ligule originates from a single epidermal cell (Smith, 1900a;Bhambie, 1963;Sporne, 1966;Gifford and Foster, 1989). In both, the ligules are attached to the adaxial leaf surface just distal to the sporangium, produce callose, achieve maturity before their corresponding leaves, and both lack chlorophyll, starch, and intercellular spaces (Smith, 1900a;Bierhorst, 1971;Horner et al, 1975;Jagels and Garner, 1979;Kristen and Biedermann, 1981;Webster, 1992).…”