Summary• Stomatal index values of fossil plants are widely used in reconstructing palaeo- [CO 2 ]. This depends upon the assumption that the stomatal index is determined by the atmospheric concentration of CO 2 ([CO 2 ]). This study investigates whether fumigation with, and resistance to, sulphur dioxide (SO 2 ) induces a reduction in the stomatal index that may affect stomatal reconstructions of palaeo-[CO 2 ] coinciding with episodes of global-scale volcanism.• Agrostis canina from Mefite di Ansanto, Italy, grow in atmospheres of elevated-[CO 2 ], SO 2 and hydrogen sulphide (H 2 S). Mefite A. canina were compared with a control population in a 'common-garden' experiment and a controlled-environment study under elevated-[CO 2 ] and SO 2 fumigation.• In A. canina, resistance to toxic volcanic gases is not associated with reduced stomatal index, and fumigation with SO 2 does not cause a decrease in stomatal initiation.