“Life is more important than football”: Comparative analysis of Tweets and Facebook comments regarding the cancellation of the 2015 African Cup of Nations in Morocco

Abstract

This study analyzes comments from two major social media, Facebook and Twitter, regarding the controversial cancellation of the 2015 African Cup of Nations (CAN) in Morocco and its transfer to Equatorial Guinea, a move precipitated by the contemporaneous outbreaks of Ebola in West Africa. Using frame analysis methodology (frames being the central ideas structuring a narrative account of an issue, event or controversy), it investigates how the sporting and health worlds are understood and conceptualized on Twitter and Facebook, in the context of a specific event. We also investigated the extent to which these frames are platform-specific. Data were collected by keyword extraction and submitted to a qualitative thematic and frame analysis, from which we identified six frames (Epidemic management, Sporting event, Political, Skepticism, Religion, and Economic). Analysis of these frames identified a number of classic issues from the sociology of not only football and epidemics but also of African political issues. The cancellation of the CAN thus provides an excellent window into the complex links between sport, heath and politics. Indeed, the online comments of social media users expressed a rich range of pre-existing frustrations, beliefs and political positions. Our results show that, in the context of the cancellation of the 2015 CAN, tweets mostly framed the event as an epidemic management issue, while Facebook comments typically framed it as an epidemic management, sporting and political event. Some themes treated in a factual way on Twitter became politicized on Facebook where, in addition, new political themes emerged. We conclude that studying social media conversations relating to a mega-sporting event could provide sociologically valuable insights about topics not typically directly associated with sport or health.

A Topic Modeling Comparison Between LDA, NMF, Top2Vec, and BERTopic to Demystify Twitter Posts

“…In this respect, the value of user-generated content on social media platforms has been wellestablished and acknowledged since their rich and subjective information allows for favorable computational analysis (Hu, 2012). For instance, recent research explored the social dynamics of sporting events based on Facebook comments (Moreau et al, 2021), while another study disclosed the social semiotics of different attractions using Instagram content (Arefieva et al, 2021). Scholars have also used Twitter posts related to the COVID-19 pandemic to construct individual's reactions (Boccia Artieri et al, 2021).…”

From Ferguson to Gaza. Sport, political sensibility, and the Israel/Palestine conflict in the age of Black Lives Matter

“…Studies involving the use of social media are increasingly common in the sociology of sport, with discourse analysis being used to explore the changing ways we are communicating (Cleland, 2014;Kilvington & Price, 2019;Moreau, et al, 2021). Critical Discourse Analysis is a form of discourse analysis that uses an interdisciplinary approach to study how power is exercised through language (Fairclough, 1995;Janks, 1997).…”

The changing faces of fandom? Exploring emerging ‘online’ and ‘offline’ fandom spaces in the English Premier League

“…Fan TV channels thus add another layer to the EPL's digital spaces that are already composed by social media, podcasts, blogs, e-zines, and online forums. As recently argued, studies examining fans use of social media are increasingly popular in the sociology of sports (Moreau et al 2021). For the continuation of the social study of football fandom, consumption, and identities it is therefore completely necessary to 'keep up' with emerging spaces on social media wherein fans interact, which are becoming increasingly defining for fan cultures locally and transnationally.…”