Life‐insurance Efficiency in China: A Comparison of Foreign and Domestic Firms

Abstract

The Chinese life-insurance industry has experienced major structural changes in recent years, primarily because of increasing demand and the entry of foreign insurers. Although the market is clearly booming, the efficiency of its growth and development is unclear. In this paper, we evaluate the efficiency of life insurers operating in China and compare foreign firms with domestic firms. We find that foreign insurers have not brought efficiency into the Chinese market, and that the market is still dominated by domestic giants. However, the gap between foreign insurers and domestic insurers is narrowing. After testing hypotheses regarding scale economy, technical progress and potential improvements, we discuss several issues of importance to life insurers, market investors and government regulators. Copyright (c) 2009 The Authors Journal compilation (c) 2009 Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.

Efficiency Analysis of Private Insurance Firms Before and After The Application of BPJS Regulations

“…This agrees with the finding of Leverty, Lin & Zhou [9] and Chen, Powers & Qiu [10], where domestic insurance had a higher level of efficiency than foreign insurance but was insignificant. This difference in yield was due to the difference in market conditions, where in China the new foreign insurance had entered the market in the 2000s, so, domestic insurance was still more dominant than foreign insurance.…”

“…In addition, in Indonesia, insurance companies are divided into two ownerships, foreign and local [40]. The efficiency levels of foreign and local companies differ due to different levels of competition after the entry of foreign companies [9,10]. This research was to find the difference of efficiency performance of local and foreign insurance companies.…”

“…Local insurance companies have higher technical efficiency than foreign companies [9]. Efficiency in local insurance was higher than the efficiency of foreign insurance on the life insurance market in China [10]. This was because foreign insurance in China was first introduced in the year 2000 and there has not been enough time to get the return from initial issued investment.…”

China's nonlife insurance market: New insights from the China Insurance Yearbook

“…4 1 While annual volumes begin in 1998, some information is available for the period 1981-1997. (Hu et al, 2009;Kweh et al, 2014), total factor productivity (Sun, 2020), economies of scale (Lu, 2019), and efficiency comparisons between domestic and foreign life insurers (Chen et al, 2009). A few life studies utilize data from other sources, most notably Swiss Re's Sigma Publications (e.g., Hwang & Gao, 2003;Hwang & Greenford, 2005).…”

Assessment of measurement and ranking of technical efficiencies of Ethiopian general insurers

“…The authors argued that domestic insurance firms are efficient than foreign insurers due to dominance by the former. However, both the categories have experienced decreasing returns to scale (Chen et al, 2009). Bawa and Navjeet (2014) have taken 4 Indian public general insurers for 21 years consisting of pre-and post-reform period and found that these insurers were comparatively better in the pre-reform period as the percentage of wastages of resources was less in this period.…”