“…We found that the reaction proceeded smoothly in 1,2-dichloroethane (DCE) to afford 2-benzhydrylidene-3,4,4,9-tetraphenyl-2,4-dihydro-1H-cyclopenta[b]naphthalene 3 a in 93 % yield within 6 h at À20 8C in the presence of ZrA C H T U N G T R E N N U N G (OTf) 4 (10 mol %, OTf = trifluoromethanesulfonate) ( 2 , and the Brønsted acid (TfOH) were not as effective as ZrA C H T U N G T R E N N U N G (OTf) 4 under the standard conditions ( Table 1, entries 1-6). When 2 b was used as a reactant, complex product mixtures were obtained at room temperature (20 8C) or even at 0 8C by using YbA C H T U N G T R E N N U N G (OTf) 3 or BF 3 ·OEt 2 as a Lewis acid in DCE (Table 1, entries 12-14). However, the Lewis acids BF 3 ·OEt 2 and Zr-A C H T U N G T R E N N U N G (OTf) 4 (10 mol %) produced 3 a in 78 and 85 % yields, respectively at À20 8C (Table 1, entries 15 and 16).…”