Lessons of DRDSI pilot projects in Ukraine

CHABANIUK, V.; DYSHLYK, O.; TARNOPOLSKIY, A.

doi:10.33841/1819-1339-2-44-69-81

Cited by 1 publication

(2 citation statements)

References 4 publications

(8 reference statements)

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…In the article [2], we considered examples of such processes -pilot services of NSDI in the eras of Web 1.0 and Web 1.0+. As a guideline for the processes of using NSDI in the work [5], we considered the processes of using the Geoportal of Poland.…”

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Practice needs to consider the problem of harmonization comprehensively, since "purely" horizontal transformational harmonizations are rare. To explain the last statement, it is enough to read the article [2]. There, in order to harmonize even simple basic administrative and territorial data of Odesa region with INSPIRE, it was necessary to use not only external tools (such as HALE), but also (vertical) knowledge and skills that the Ukrainian side did not have.…”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Harmonization strategy of the spatial information infrastructure of Ukraine with INSPIRE. system approach

Chabaniuk,

Dyshlyk

2024

ZKMZ

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Van Gigch's system approach was applied to consider the option of systemic harmonization of the National Spatial Information Infrastructure of Ukraine (NSII) with INSPIRE. The article focuses on its most important part - the strategy of harmonization or, more specifically, strategic harmonization. The proposed strategic harmonization is suitable for practical implementation. For this purpose, NSII is understood as an extension of National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI), and NSII and INSPIRE are represented by general systems (GS), whose practical feasibility is achieved by exemplification/interpretation by spatial information systems (SpIS) and certain their extensions - SpISb. The main attention is paid to the relation between the NSII and INSPIRE, with an emphasis on the harmonization relation. Possible alternatives to the problems or their solutions are not considered. In particular, the likely recent shift of interest from NSDI/NSII/INSPIRE to IGIF (Integrated Geospatial Information Framework) is not considered. This is possible because van Gigch's system approach used allows scaling, in this case - upwards, with the addition of higher levels of the hierarchy such as IGIF to the consideration. It is shown that, in the context of harmonization with INSPIRE, it is necessary to examine the harmonization of GS on at least three epistemological levels. GS corresponding to these levels can be called: strategic, tactical and operational. The GS for harmonization with INSPIRE can be represented by an integrated hierarchy or a unification of three GS components of these three levels. In the case of unification, each component of the collective agreement can be considered separately, but the context of harmonization must be mandatory. In particular, in strategic harmonization, it is mandatory to define its hierarchical relations with the "corresponding" tactical harmonization. Two main results were obtained in the article: 1) scientific - the structure of the phenomenon "harmonization of Ukrainian SII with INSPIRE" was defined, 2) practical - it was proved that the specified phenomenon is adequately represented by the GS and the corresponding SpISb.

show abstract

Section: System Approach and General Scheme Of Researchmentioning

confidence: 99%

mentioning

confidence: 99%