Lessons from Structural Analysis of a Great Gothic Cathedral: Canterbury Cathedral as a Case Study

Abstract

Damage in Gothic cathedrals can occur due to single extreme events or long term processes, often associated to large deformations and cracking. This paper, presents the damage survey and structural assessment of a UNESCO world heritage site and one of the oldest, most visited and most known Christian temples in the UK: Canterbury Cathedral, in Kent. Inspection and damage survey showed repetitive crack patterns on the vault's intrados, with more severity in the south aisle, including namely outward rotating movement and cracking in the south flying buttresses. Ambient vibration tests were carried out to identify the structure modal properties. A FE model of a typical transversal section of the nave and lateral aisles was prepared, and calibrated based on the tests. Nonlinear static analyses were performed, considering the main parameters of influence to the structure, as the construction process, the infill volume, the presence of lateral thrusts from the nave's roof and differential settlements. A validated FE model, presenting sufficient correlation with the existing damage was used to determine the safety factors for lateral and vertical loading, which according to the local hazard are considered adequate. A comparison with limit analysis, based in the static approach, was also carried out.

Sustainable management of heritage buildings in long-term perspective (SyMBoL): current knowledge and further research needs

“…architectural, artistic, historical, conservation features; consolidation and restoration actions; monitored zones and used tools; visitors number). HBIM permits to generate a centralized repository for heritage info management, preventive conservation (Bruno et al, 2018), building rehabilitation and restoration (Do gan and G€ ull€ u, 2022;Karanikoloudis et al, 2020) and sustainable objective achievements (Munarim and Ghisi, 2016;Atmaca et al, 2021). Such repository allows to structure the information collected during each stage of HHB service life and to effectively analyse the data.…”

Ancient restorations: computer-based structural approach for the identification and reinterpretation of the Medracen’s constructive sequence

“…Several methods and tools aiming at studying these geometrically complex structures have been made available (see, e.g. Whiting, Shin, Wang, Ochsendorf & Durand, 2012;Barazzetti et al, 2015, Pelà et al, 2016Benito Pradillo, 2017;Karanikoloudis, Lourenço, Alejo & Mendes, 2020) and are continuously developed to attain the most valid and reliable results. However, as for ancient buildings, mainly those with basic geometry (such as the Pyramids), computer-based analysis-diagnosis studies are less presented (see, e.g.…”

Effect of Buttress Form on Transverse Seismic Resistance of High Masonry Walls

“…For example, in their study about the possible influences of the construction stage and long-term deformations on the current state of the Mallorca Cathedral, Roca et al (2013) laid emphasis on both classical and flying buttresses of the structure. To give another example, Karanikoloudis et al (2020) Above, studies about both classical wall buttresses and flying buttresses were given. All of them are very precious works.…”