Lecturers’ vs. students’ perceptions of the accessibility of instructional materials

Abstract

This goal of this study was to examine the differences between lecturers and students' perceptions of the accessibility of instructional materials. The perceptions of 12 mature computing distance education students and 12 computing lecturers were examined using the knowledge elicitation techniques of card sorting and laddering. The study showed that lecturers had pedagogical views while students tended to concentrate on surface attributes such as appearance. Students perceived instructional materials containing visual representations as most accessible. This has two implications for the professional development of computing lecturers designing instructional materials. First, lecturers need to appreciate the differences between expert and novice views of accessibility and how students will engage with the materials. Second, lecturers need to understand that learners perceive instructional materials containing visual representations as more accessible compared to 'text only' versions. Hence greater use of these may enable students to engage more readily in learning. Given that print is the ubiquitous teaching medium this is likely to have implications for students and lecturers in other disciplines.

Developing web-based training for public health practitioners: what can we learn from a review of five disciplines?

“…Providing visual appeal is an aspect of design and layout that is relatively simple, yet significantly important to keeping users at a web-based training [28,29,46]. The use of color, graphics, video clips, audio clips and animation adds to the visual appeal by gaining the attention of users and increasing their engagement with the training [45,47,48]. However, the use of graphics and multimedia should be appropriate for the training topic, balanced with the content, and informational as opposed to decorative [34,44].…”

A reusable e-learning tool for paediatric physio-therapy education: a preliminary report

“…7,9 There is evidence that in designing instructional materials student perceptions will be dominated by accessibility in terms of visuals and ease of engagement whereas teacher-designers are more likely to consider pedagogical aspects. 19 Thus novices apparently want different learning materials than the expert who is designing the instructional package. Indeed a number of studies have identified visual components as key for learners.…”

Análisis de la satisfacción de la actividad docente medida a través del alumnado en contextos universitarios siguiendo el Modelo de Calidad de Situación Educativa

“…A lo largo de los últimos años se han realizado diversas investigaciones donde se miden las variables implicadas en la satisfacción del proceso de enseñanza y aprendizaje teniendo en cuenta las funciones del docente en la etapa universitaria. En el estudio de Price (2007) docentes y estudiantes valoraron los contenidos académicos que proporcionaba el profesorado y se encontraron diferencias, ya que los docentes valoraban el material desde una perspectiva pedagógica y el alumnado centraba su valoración en características superficiales del material (como pueden ser la apariencia o la cuantía de información recogida). En la misma línea, en la investigación realizada por Tárrega, et al (2012), el alumnado consideraba que los mapas conceptuales y sitios web facilitan el aprendizaje significativo y su progreso dentro de la "zona de desarrollo" conectando la nueva información con sus conocimientos previos.…”