Learning theories for artificial intelligence promoting learning processes

Abstract

This paper discusses a three‐level model that synthesizes and unifies existing learning theories to model the roles of artificial intelligence (AI) in promoting learning processes. The model, drawn from developmental psychology, computational biology, instructional design, cognitive science, complexity and sociocultural theory, includes a causal learning mechanism that explains how learning occurs and works across micro, meso and macro levels. The model also explains how information gained through learning is aggregated, or brought together, as well as dissipated, or released and used within and across the levels. Fourteen roles for AI in education are proposed, aligned with the model's features: four roles at the individual or micro level, four roles at the meso level of teams and knowledge communities and six roles at the macro level of cultural historical activity. Implications for research and practice, evaluation criteria and a discussion of limitations are included. Armed with the proposed model, AI developers can focus their work with learning designers, researchers and practitioners to leverage the proposed roles to improve individual learning, team performance and building knowledge communities. Practitioner notesWhat is already known about this topic Numerous learning theories exist with significant cross‐over of concepts, duplication and redundancy in terms and structure that offer partial explanations of learning. Frameworks concerning learning have been offered from several disciplines such as psychology, biology and computer science but have rarely been integrated or unified. Rethinking learning theory for the age of artificial intelligence (AI) is needed to incorporate computational resources and capabilities into both theory and educational practices. What this paper adds A three‐level theory (ie, micro, meso and macro) of learning that synthesizes and unifies existing theories is proposed to enhance computational modelling and further develop the roles of AI in education. A causal model of learning is defined, drawing from developmental psychology, computational biology, instructional design, cognitive science and sociocultural theory, which explains how learning occurs and works across the levels. The model explains how information gained through learning is aggregated, or brought together, as well as dissipated, or released and used within and across the levels. Fourteen roles for AI in education are aligned with the model's features: four roles at the individual or micro level, four roles at the meso level of teams and knowledge communities and six roles at the macro level of cultural historical activity. Implications for practice and policy Researchers may benefit from referring to the new theory to situate their work as part of a larger context of the evolution and complexity of individual and organizational learning and learning systems. Mechanisms newly discovered and explained by future researchers may be better understood as contributions to a common framework unifying the scientific understanding of learning theory.

Artificial intelligence and medical education: application in classroom instruction and student assessment using a pharmacology & therapeutics case study

“…AI techniques have potential to stimulate and advance instructional and learning sciences. More recently a three- level model that synthesizes and unifies existing learning theories to model the roles of AIs in promoting learning process has been proposed [ 26 ]. The different components of our study rely upon these paradigms and learning theories as the theoretical underpinning.…”

ChatGPT from the students' point of view – Lessons from a pilot study using ChatGPT in business higher education

“…To discuss the changes in the content and the teaching methods of higher education in its complexity, Gibson et al (2023), for example, propose a model that can capture the effects of AI at three levels: in supporting (1) the individual (micro level), in which the role of AI is to support individual learners, develop personalized learning pathways and strategies, and enhance individual knowledge and skills; (2) the community (meso level), when the focus is on learning processes, collaboration, knowledge sharing and community knowledge building of teams, peer groups and knowledge communities; and (3) the cultural learning processes (macro), when we look at the role of AI from a socio-cultural development perspective.…”

Activity Theory-based Ecosystem for Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED)

“…Accordingly, as information technology continues to transform into a cognitive tool, Activity Theory can assist in analyzing the role of computers within a social and cultural context (Tan, 2019). With AI advancing into the micro, meso, and macro levels of the learning process (Gibson et al, 2023), Activity Theory provides an appropriate illustration of the dynamic interactions and contradictions associated with AIED (H. . Therefore, by anchoring on the collective activity system of Engeström's (2000Engeström's ( , 2007, the AIED design process can be clearly explained.…”