Learning relationships in community-based service-learning: a social network analysis

Abstract

Background Little is known about the social learning of students within community-based clinical placements and ways in which it can be supported. In an allied health service-learning program, we analysed students’ learning relationships to quantify what, and from whom students learnt. Methods We conducted a social learning network survey in four domains of learning (clinical knowledge, procedural skills, professional development, and complex determinants of health) to explore learning relationships ( ties ) with other people ( alters) that students ( egos ) formed during their placement. We quantified how different roles (supervisors, health professionals, administrators, peers, schoolteachers, and clients) contributed to the students’ learning in each of the four domains. We used exponential random graph models (ERGMs) to test which relational processes contributed to the structure of the observed learning networks. Results Data was available from a complete cohort of 10 students on placement in a network of 69 members, thus providing information on 680 potential learning relations. Students engaged in similar ways in the domains of clinical knowledge, procedural skills, and professional development. Learning relations with academic supervisors were significantly more likely. Also students reported reciprocal learning relations with peers – i.e. they formed learning pairs. This effect was absent in learning networks about complex determinants of health (including socio-economic and cultural factors). Instead, local administrative staff were significantly more often the source of learning about the local contextual factors. Conclusions Understanding the structure of student learning networks through social network analysis helps identify targeted strategies to enhance learning in community-based service-learning programs. Our findings suggest students recognised important learning from each other and from administrative personnel that is unrelated to the content of their placement. Based on this insight clinical educators could prepare students to become agentic learners, learning with each other and from sources outside their program. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (10.1186/s12909-019-1522-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Building Community and Medical School Partnerships: Impact on Undergraduate Medical Education and Research

“…Similar to ours, another CSL model describes the effectiveness of such programs in developing the participants self-reported empathy, cultural competence, communication skills and openness towards peer teaching (3,31). Peer learning and support, which is another important nding of our study, has also been described by researchers as enhancing medical knowledge, procedural skills (32) along with the professional development of all students involved in such interactions (5,33,34). While developing a culture of community outreach, CSL programs similar to ours, have also shown improvement in student attitudes towards patients (35) and development of social accountability (36)(37)(38)(39).…”

Value of social network analysis for developing and evaluating complex healthcare interventions: a scoping review

“… 44 SNA analysis is further strengthened because it is based on the number of relationships instead of only the number of individuals. 43 Additionally, the use of SNA programmes to analyse data was reported as a strength in terms of the ease of use but as a limitation in terms of the need for special training and experience. 19 27 44 The visualisation of SNA results can strengthen the interpretation of the results.…”

Students' social networks are diverse, dynamic and deliberate when transitioning to clinical training

“…For example, the concept of deliberate network management is likely generalisable to all transitioning medical trainees given it being found not only here but relates to network intentionality in general SNA literature. Eight participants may appear low; however, we were interested in the 128‐134 ties and properties of those ties 52 . Given the intense data collection methods, only a small number of participants were necessary to produce this rich, multimodal dataset at two time‐points 39 .…”

“…Mapping social networks could help institutions recognise brokers 10 and support them. More SNA research in other health professions education fields, like allied health, 52 could provide holistic data on how networks of health professions interact or not.…”