Learning health systems need to bridge the ‘two cultures’ of clinical informatics and data science

Abstract

BackgroundUK health research policy and plans for population health management are predicated upon transformative knowledge discovery from operational ‘Big Data’. Learning health systems require not only data, but feedback loops of knowledge into changed practice. This depends on knowledge management and application, which in turn depends upon effective system design and implementation. Biomedical informatics is the interdisciplinary field at the intersection of health science, social science and information science and technology that spans this entire scope.IssuesIn the UK, the separate worlds of health data science (bioinformatics, ‘Big Data’) and effective healthcare system design and implementation (clinical informatics, ‘Digital Health’) have operated as ‘two cultures’. Much National Health Service and social care data is of very poor quality. Substantial research funding is wasted on ‘data cleansing’ or by producing very weak evidence. There is not yet a sufficiently powerful professional community or evidence base of best practice to influence the practitioner community or the digital health industry.RecommendationThe UK needs increased clinical informatics research and education capacity and capability at much greater scale and ambition to be able to meet policy expectations, address the fundamental gaps in the discipline’s evidence base and mitigate the absence of regulation. Independent evaluation of digital health interventions should be the norm, not the exception.ConclusionsPolicy makers and research funders need to acknowledge the existing gap between the ‘two cultures’ and recognise that the full social and economic benefits of digital health and data science can only be realised by accepting the interdisciplinary nature of biomedical informatics and supporting a significant expansion of clinical informatics capacity and capability.

Leveraging real-world data to investigate multiple sclerosis disease behavior, prognosis, and treatment

“…Available natural language processing or other techniques that extract information from unstructured data are of limited use, 18 but utilization of structured data fields makes the information more useful for research. Systematic capture of health status data can inform the care of individual patients contributing the data and improve disease management generally, a so-called “learning health system.” 19 This model may be more scalable than passive data collection or active data collection added to clinical care, increasing the range of data elements collected and improving the representativeness of the patients (Table 3 presents an example).…”

Big Data for Biomedical Education with a Focus on the COVID-19 Era: An Integrative Review of the Literature

“…A transition towards "knowledge discovery", "knowledge management", and "knowledge application", in such a way that big data become actionable and operational data, is absolutely necessary, even if it is highly challenging [57]. A shift towards a "competency-based medical educational system" is also of paramount importance [58,59].…”

“…To develop a real learning health system, the different 'cultures' and 'languages' underlying it have to communicate and interact with each other in an inter-, multi-disciplinary perspective [58,60]. Boundaries have to be crossed and the gaps have to be filled [58].…”

Data saves lives

“…The strategy rightly aims to recruit more analysts and data scientists. However, a learning health and care system is sociotechnical—it includes people working in interdisciplinary teams, not just technology and data science—so must include a broader range of informatics skills 1718…”