Learning from the past to inform the future – A survey of consultant nurses in emergency care

Abstract

Summary This paper reports the findings of a survey of UK consultant nurses in emergency care. The purpose of the survey was to elicit information regarding level of preparation for the consultant nurse role, the use of formal competency frameworks, current clinical scope of practice and perspectives on future preparation for the role. A semi-structured questionnaire was emailed to consultant nurses in emergency care. Respondents had an average of only 2 years in post and for 24% of respondents this was their second post as a consultant nurse. The survey identified that three quarters of the respondents had no specific preparation for the consultant nurse role. The remainder had varying levels of preparation ranging from brief induction to 6-month clinical training. It could be argued that this diversity of preparation is a reflection of the lack of clarity regarding the consultant nurse role and the ill-defined organisational frameworks within which some consultant nurse posts were established. With the exception of the expert practice domain and clinical leadership, the majority of respondents felt under prepared for one or more elements of the consultant nurse role. Clinically their scope of practice ranged from managing patients with minor illness or injury, to leading resuscitation teams. There was great

Should aspiring consultant nurses follow a medical training programme?

“…Would the 'essence' of nursing be lost and would the concept of role substitution be reinforced by following a similar programme of preparation? It could also be argued that a major issue, which arises from both the literature and also from the respondents in this study, is the ambiguity surrounding this role and where it lies within organisations and the professional hierarchy in the NHS (Woodward et al, 2005;Charters et al, 2005). Nursing and in particular the role of the consultant nurse requires the development of a stronger professional identity rather than the erosion of this.…”

Exploring the relationship between social identity and workplace jurisdiction for new nursing roles: A case study approach

“…Successive studies have identified that the introduction of new roles at organisational level has mixed results (Read et al, 2001;Guest et al, 2004;Charters et al, 2005;Booth et al, 2006;Lathlean, 2007). New roles are ambiguous until they become established (Martin and Hutchinson, 1999) leading to difficulties in developing clear role definitions and role boundaries (e.g.…”

Professional development: Integrating the consultant physiotherapist role within a musculoskeletal interface service

“…These posts will vary slightly across the UK, but all should have at least 50% clinical commitment. Previous work has identified that undertaking research, interpreting research and translating findings into clinical practice still remained a challenge (Charters et al, 2005;Woodward et al, 2005).…”