Learning data science in elementary school mathematics: a comparative curriculum analysis

Abstract

Background Data literacy is increasingly important in today’s data-driven world. Students across many educational systems first formally learn about data in elementary school not as a separate subject but via the mathematics curriculum. This experience can create tensions in the priorities of learning and assessment given the presence of other foundational mathematics content domains such as numbers, algebra, measurement, and geometry. There is a need to study data literacy in comparison to these other content domains in elementary mathematics. To address this need, we developed a methodology motivated by thinking curriculum theory and aligned with international assessment framework, for comparative analysis across mathematics content domains. This methodology examined increasing levels of cognitive domains from knowing to applying to reasoning across mathematics content domains. Intended, assessed, and attained curricula were analyzed using Singapore as a case study, combined with broader comparisons to attainments in four East Asian countries in TIMSS, an international large-scale assessment. Results We found that learning in the data domain had very limited coverage in intended and assessed curricula in Singapore. However, compared to other mathematics content domains, the data curriculum placed heavier emphasis on higher-order cognitive domains including the use of generally difficult mixed data visualizations. This demanding curriculum in Singapore was associated with the highest attainment in the data domain among average 4th grade Singaporean students relative to students in four East Asian countries in TIMSS, as analyzed by quantile regression. However, lower-performing Singaporean students at the 10th percentile generally did not outperform their East Asian peers. We further found very limited applications of data in other mathematics domains or cross-domain learning more generally. Conclusion Our study offers a comparative analysis of the data curriculum in elementary school mathematics education. While the data curriculum was cognitively demanding and translated to very high average attainments of Singaporean students, the curriculum did not equally help weaker Singaporean students, with implications on current discourse on equity–excellence trade-off in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education. Our study further highlights the lack of cross-domain learning in mathematics involving data. Despite the broad applicability of data science, elementary school students’ first formal experience with data may lack emphasis on its cross-domain applications, suggesting a need to further integrate data skills and competencies into the mathematics curriculum and beyond.

Development of Kvisoft-Based Flipbook Learning Media on Learning Outcomes in Natural Sciences on the Human Circulatory System

“…Learning media play a role in increasing students' interest in learning, which is expected to improve their learning outcomes. This is because learning media can stimulate and direct students' attention, sparking curiosity and enthusiasm for learning (El-Hamamsy et al, 2023;Ow-Yeong et al, 2023). Similar opinions are expressed by Dewi et al (2020) and Setiyani et al (2022), stating that learning media can facilitate students' learning.…”

Innovating Education: A Comprehensive Review of STEM Education Approaches

“…• Online and Blended Learning: Leveraging online platforms for teaching and learning, allowing for more personalized and accessible STEM education (Owston et al, 2020). • Data Analytics: Using data analytics tools in the curriculum to teach students how to interpret and use data, an essential skill in modern STEM professions (Ow-Yeong et al, 2023).…”

“…• Improved Academic Performance: Studies have shown that students engaged in comprehensive STEM education often perform better not only in science and mathematics but also in other academic areas, due to the interdisciplinary approach and emphasis on analytical skills (Eroğlu & Bektaş, 2022;Nağaç & Kalayci, 2021;Taşdemir, 2022). • Development of Technical Skills: STEM education equips students with specific technical skills, such as programming, data analysis, and scientific experimentation, which are increasingly important in the digital age (Baterna et al, 2020;Ow-Yeong et al, 2023). • Fostering Creativity and Innovation: By integrating technology and engineering principles with science and mathematics, STEM education encourages creative solutions and innovation, skills highly valued in various fields (Eroğlu & Bektaş, 2022;Sonthong et al, 2023).…”

Uncovering network structure relating academic achievement, motivation, and schooling experience using structure learning of directed acyclic graphs

“…We used both Singapore (N = 5986) and Korea (N = 3893) datasets for Grade 4 science. These two Asian countries have high-performing educational systems, exhibit seemingly similar cultural values, and are commonly studied in a comparative manner (Kim, 2019;Ow-Yeong et al, 2023;Sandoval-Hernández & Białowolski, 2016).…”