Leadership, politics, and communication: challenges of the epidemiology workforce during emergency response

Abstract

Background Improving the epidemiological response to emergencies requires an understanding of who the responders are, their role and skills, and the challenges they face during responses. In this paper, we explore the role of the epidemiologist and identify challenges they face during emergency response. Methods We conducted a cross-sectional survey to learn more about epidemiologists who respond to public health emergencies. The online survey included open and closed-ended questions on challenges faced while responding, the roles of epidemiology responders, self-rating of skills, and support needed and received. We used purposive sampling to identify participants and a snowballing approach thereafter. We compared data by a number of characteristics, including national or international responder on their last response prior to the survey. We analysed the data using descriptive, content, and exploratory factor analysis. Results We received 166 responses from individuals with experience in emergency response. The most frequently reported challenge was navigating the political dynamics of a response, which was more common for international responders than national. National responders experienced fewer challenges related to culture, language, and communication. Epidemiology responders reported a lack of response role clarity, limited knowledge sharing, and communication issues during emergency response. Sixty-seven percent of participants reported they needed support to do their job well; males who requested support were statistically more likely to receive it than females who asked. Conclusions Our study identified that national responders have additional strengths, such as better understanding of the local political environment, language, and culture, which may in turn support identification of local needs and priorities. Although this research was conducted prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the results are even more relevant now. This research builds on emerging evidence on how to strengthen public health emergency response and provides a platform to begin a global conversation to address operational issues and the role of the international epidemiology responder.

Challenges of epidemiological investigation work in the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative study of the epidemiology workforce in Guangdong Province, China

“…This could enable greater human resources use efficiency and ensure that the public health workforce can effectively manage health security. 13 …”

The Differential Effect of Women Politicians' Communication, Efficacy, and Ideology in Building Citizens' Political Satisfaction and Trust: A Case of a Developing Nation

“…One section collected demographic questions. The scale for political communication with seven items was adapted from Parry et al (2022). The political efficacy of the politicians was measured with two items adapted from Ariely (2013), explaining the politicians' ability and effectiveness to communicate with the citizens and resolve their issues contract basis.…”

Team effectiveness: epidemiologists' perception of collective performance during emergency response

“…(12) The impact of team dynamics, team con dence, and team management during emergency response in uence the team effectiveness, and in turn impact the effectiveness of response. (11,12) The stress of a crisis, however, often makes teamwork and collaboration di cult to sustain. (29,30) Tuckman's team lifecycle is important to consider in regards to leadership also.…”

“…Our ndings on leadership corroborate previous research that indicates team effectiveness and innovation improve when leadership is agile to team needs and clear with team roles. (4,6,11,37).…”

“…(4,(7)(8)(9)(10) The combined impact of team dynamics, team con dence and team management during emergency response in uence the teams effectiveness. (11) Valid and reliable teamwork assessment tools may highlight factors requiring intervention to strengthen individual and team performance.…”