Aims To investigate whether pseudophakic and phakic rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) patterns differ. Methods Retrospective review of electronic database of patients, aged 50 years or over, presenting to our vitreoretinal service. Data included baseline characteristics, digital drawings, and outcomes. Retinal drawings were analysed in a masked fashion for site, size, and number of retinal breaks. Comparisons were made between the following groups and subgroups: pseudophakic eyes, phakic eyes, phakic eyes with cataract, and phakic eyes without cataract. Results Of 500 eyes included, 146 were pseudophakic; 177 of the phakic eyes had cataract. The following were significant by univariate analysis: pseudophakic patients were older than phakic patients in general, but the same age as patients with cataract; in the pseudophakic group, there were lower proportions of females and of patients presenting with vitreous haemorrhage or with large or superotemporal breaks; higher proportions of pseudophakic eyes had small breaks and inferonasal breaks. Some differences remained significant when comparing pseudophakia eyes with cataract. Multivariate analysis comparing pseudophakia with phakia confirmed a lower chance in pseudophakia of large breaks, vitreous haemorrhage and superotemporal breaks, but higher chance of detached inferior breaks. Some variables were age dependent. Conclusion Differences were found between pseudophakic and phakic RRD patterns. These suggest special pathogenetic mechanisms in pseudophakic retinal detachment, which could help explain increased incidences of RRD after cataract surgery.