Laparoscopic radical prostatectomy outcome data: how should surgeon’s performance be reported? A retrospective learning curve analysis of two surgeons

Abstract

ObjectiveTo document the learning curve for the laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (LRP) procedure and discuss the optimal usage of prospectively documented outcome data for reporting a surgeon’s performance.Materials and methodsUsing prospectively collected data from the first series of patients to undergo LRP by two surgeons in the same institution, linear and logistic regression multivariate analyses per 25 patients were carried out to graphically represent the surgical learning curve for operative time, blood loss, complications, length of stay (LOS), and positive margins. Surgeon A carried out 275 operations between 2003–2009; Surgeon B carried out 225 between 2008–2012.ResultsLearning curves showing continuous improvement of each of the above outcomes were demonstrated for both cohorts. For surgeon A, a plateau was observed for LOS and T2 positive margins after 100 and 150 surgeries respectively. No such plateau was observed for surgeon B.ConclusionOn documenting these learning curves and discussion of the reporting methods used, we concluded that the most informative outcome measure, with the least potential observer bias was T2 positive margins. Whether as a single measure or in combination with others, this has potential for use as an objective outcome representative of improvement in a surgeon’s skill over time.

Guy’s cancer cohort – real world evidence for cancer pathways

“…It helps accelerate evidence generation through providing observational studies that can generate new hypotheses and support policy makers. Prior to its formal development, a wide variety of studies had already been published using the clinical data of GSTT's cancer patients (based on individual ethics or audit approval) including various studies focused on prostate cancer [4][5][6][7][8][9], breast cancer [10][11][12][13] and renal cancer [14]. The below case study shows how data from Guy's Cancer Cohort was used to address a clinically important question for bladder cancer:…”

Analysis of the Learning Curve of Surgeons without Previous Experience in Laparoscopy to Perform Robot-Assisted Radical Prostatectomy

“…There was a significant decrease for one surgeon and a declining trend for the second one regarding postoperative complications. There was no difference regarding the rates of compromised surgical margins between the groups of patients [ 20 ].…”

Our Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy Experiences: Single Center Results

“…100-150 vakadan sonra cerrahın tecrübesi plato çizerek sabitlenir. Bir cerrahın yeterliliğini gösteren bir çok faktör olsa da T2 cerrahi sınır pozitifliği cerrahın yeterliliğini gösteren en objektif parametredir [8]. Bizim çalışmamızda 5 (%21,7) hastada cerrahi sınır pozitif olarak geldi.…”