Lack of Effect of Hypertonic Sodium Bicarbonate on QRS Duration in Patients Taking Therapeutic Doses of Class IC Antiarrhythmic Drugs

Abstract

Hypertonic sodium bicarbonate (HSB) has been reported to reduce the toxicity of Class IC antiarrhythmic agents in rats and, anecdotally, in patients. A pilot study was conducted of the safety and efficacy of HSB for reversing the electrocardiographic effects of therapeutic doses of encainide or flecainide in ten patients taking these drugs for chronic ventricular arrhythmias. Patients had a mean drug-induced QRS prolongation before treatment of 27.6 +/- 8.8%. Each patient received a single dose of HSB 100 mEq or normal saline IV over 5 minutes on two separate occasions. The administration of treatments was blinded and balanced. There were no important side effects of HSB. Venous blood pH, CO2 content and sodium concentration were all significantly increased by HSB in comparison to saline. No differences were found during the 2-hour observation period in the primary endpoint, QRS duration, the PR or QT intervals, or the frequency of premature ventricular beats. It was concluded that HSB 100 mEq does not reduce QRS duration in patients taking therapeutic doses of flecainide or encainide. Because HSB was well tolerated, investigation of its use in higher doses or in patients with overt toxicity due to Class IC drugs is feasible.

Acute Propafenone Toxicity Discovered after Unknown Onset of Symptoms

“…The treatment for propafenone intoxication is controversial and different therapeutic approaches can be applied. In a study with class 1C antiarrythmics bicarbonate alone was not effective reversing ECG effects in therapeutic doses [9]. But in theory sodium bicarbonate is effective in sodium canal blocking agent toxicity as in TCA toxicity.…”

Spontaneous Resolution Of Arrhythmia in Propafenone Intoxication: A Rare Case Report

“…Activated charcoal administration, intravenous glucagon, sodium bicarbonate, hypertonic saline, insulin and lipid emulsion therapy are beneficial 5 . Theoretically, sodium bicarbonate is effective in sodium channel blocking agent toxicity, but in a study with class 1C antiarrhythmics, bicarbonate alone was not effective in reversing ECG effects at therapeutic doses 7 . Again, in an animal research study comparing the efficacy of insulin and sodium bicarbonate therapy in acute propafenone toxicity, insulin therapy was found to be more effective 8 .…”

Overdose of Propafenone Surreptitiously Sold as “Percocet”

“…Pentel et al describe hypertonic sodium bicarbonate as ineffective at decreasing QRS in patients taking class IC antidysrhythmics (6). Some have suggested that the administration of an anticonvulsant is crucial in the treatment of seizures associated with propafenone overdose (7).…”